First the video...
Now we'll let John Podheretz (of all people) explain:
At first blush, this seems like a genuinely great campaign ad — the story of how Mitt Romney basically closed down his business, Bain Capital, in 1996 when the daughter of one of his partners went missing in New York City and Romney sent dozens and finally hundreds of employees to New York to engage in a massive search through the streets for her. It was indeed a selfless and noble thing to do. However, the ad implies Melissa Gay had been kidnapped or something equally sinister, and that is not what happened. As a quick search of the New York Times and Boston Globe archives reveals, she went missing after she traveled to New York from Ridgefield, Conn., on her own, took Ecstasy at a concert on Randalls Island, ended up at a party under the Whitestone Bridge in The Bronx, met a boy there who took her to his house in New Jersey, and stayed with him for a few days, too embarrassed (I would wager) to call her parents and have them come get her. No charges were filed against the boy, which suggests her presence in his house was consensual. I’m sure it was a nightmarish time for her parents, and it was unquestionably was a noble thing Romney did to step in and direct the resources of his firm, including its employees, to search for her. But a) she wasn’t in need of “saving” in the way the ad’s narrative implies and b) there’s no evidence in the open record that the Bain Capital search, wonderfully well-intentioned, was responsible for Melissa’s safe return to her family.
Now let's get down to brass tacks. First off, I guess you have to give credit where credit is due. Romney, along with the other directors of Bain Capital decided to shut down their leveraged buy-out, job-shedding, Grand Cayman tax-sheltering ways for a few days because one of his greed-head partners lost one of his seven kids (a fourteen year-old girl, no less) in New York City. While I find Robert Gay's admission that he is a shitty father somewhat refreshing, I think it reflects an admirable amount of loyalty on Gay's part to publicly admit his shortcomings, which is no doubt no Mittigated by the knowledge that Bain Capital has the potential to grow exponentially with Romney as the President, in much the same way that KBR/Halliburton has benefited from Dick Cheney's latest career stop. But, you know, without the rape.
Well played, Bain Capital. A little bit of personal pain for a big payoff down the road. That's the Bain Way.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight

Support this site!
Keep up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
No Rich White Child Left Behind.
I’m not watching the ad. Did they, you know, pay the employees?
Few things piss me off more than watching some captain of industry force his employees into taking time off from their jobs to go do volunteer work for which the employer then claims PR and possibly tax credits. (Particularly when you leave unchanged deadlines and the amount of work they are required to do for you and the “time off” simply represents less time in which to accomplish their actual jobs.) In this case, it sounds like the employees were forced to leave home and family for a few days, as well. Could they not have, I dunno, posted a fucking reward?
Employees do not sign on to become the Mounties, nor do they sign on to pick up roadsides or collect canned food or donate to the United Way. They don’t take your job to help out your favorite causes, and especially not so you can run a bunch of ads telling the country what swell people you are for making them do it. Let them do their own volunteer work and their own charity, and don’t take credit for their efforts, for example in a campaign ad designed to get you elected president so you can make life even more miserable for people who aren’t captains of industry.
Isn’t there a Missing Persons Department of the NYPD for handling reports of, you know, missing persons?
Of course, it was less selfless the time Mitt shutdown his business to have his employees shovel snow, rescue Tagg from a Greenwich Village disco or had them get his magical knickers from the Holy Dry Cleaners.
But you can only make one ad at a time I guess.
Missing white girl? Missing rich white girl who was good looking enough to get high and picked up by some sleezebag at a concert? Why the hell didn’t they just call the media- they would have been all over that like stink on shit. Nancy Grace would have tracked her down in a heartbeat- she would have found her quicker than a record club can get your new address.
It’s Mitt’s Ashley ad. I sure hope the Dems have cued up some similar “Hilary (or Obama or Edwards) saves the pretty white girl” ads, because they seem to be golden.
And I was thinking along the same lines as D. Sidhe — it’s nice that Mitt runs everyone’s lives so he can demand that they all pack up and go to New York on his whim, but how inefficient is it to send hundreds of tourists wandering through the streets of NYC looking for someone? Half of them can’t even seem to find the Statue of Liberty when they’re there, and it’s 151 feet tall and has its own island.
Is there a word for these “sons of famous fathers who go off the deep end”? Last night I read through the scary Alec stories, both here and at the Lake. Then I see Mitt and JPutz in one post, and of course there is number one idiot son in the WH. I need some vocabulary help here.
How did they get all of those employees to NYC? Did Mitt strap them to the roof of the station wagon?
Whoa there, big fella!
Clueless hordes wandering the streets of a big city to “find” someone?
Jumpin’ Jeebus, is anyone really stoopid enough to not see the… well, stoopidity of that idea?
If so, I will happily sell them my own Participation Share in America’s Earliest Caucus, thereby enabling them to shape the rest of the country to their whims and, possibly, score some hot political booty in the process.
I don’t know why everybody is ragging on the Mittster for his selfless deed. If it had been Rudy on the case, the missing girl and her luckless paramour would have been found 73% faster and for 50% less cost.
Not to mention that the “kidnapper” would have been shot 242 times and had a plunger, and a piano, shoved up his ass.
Wouldn’t you be absolutely mortified if this story is about you? Can you imagine the shock/shame/desire for revenge that this “missing daughter” is feeling right now after this ad hit the airwaves?
Tbogg is right, the guy is a shitty father, and he’s given us not one, but two examples all rolled up nicely into a Natalie Holloway (almost) moment.
So um, can we revisit this now?
I guess torture sites and rape shipping containers are an improvement?
I don’t get it — if Mitt is all down with the Holy Spirit™ and has the Magic Mormon Underwear™, couldn’t he just have fired up the trumpet and gotten Holy Moroni™ to go find the girl for him? What’s the point of being all righteous if you’ve still got to schlep the entire office to New York to pretend to be looking for a needle in a haystack?
Oh, wait, you mean the whole thing might really have been a PR exercise, because — as heydave points out above — “going to NY to look for her” is about as stupid as it gets and, really, a sign of pathetically baaad decision making on the part of the guy who wants to be our new
prophetpresident.“Gay’s daughter, when they found her in the basement of that home, was shivering through detox after a massive dose of ecstasy. Doctors later told Gay that he was indeed fortunate - his daughter probably would not have lasted another day.”
For anybody interested in facts, there is no danger when the drug wears off. (Detoxing is an explosive, but not quite accurate description of “sobering up.”)
Ecstasy can give you the chills, because it raises your body temperature, but it is not a drug that you overdose on, unless it was spiked with other drugs like meth.
Finally, who the fuck lets their 14 year old daughter go into NYC alone, even if it is two o’clock in the afternoon?
A close business partner thinks his daughter is kidnapped and Mitt does everything he can to help.
Now, can someone tell me why that makes him different than anybody else, other than the fact that they just can’t order their employees to start searching for a girl who was partying with some guy in his apartment for a few days?