David Brooks sees great things in the next generation of conservative gasbags:
Among the many dark tidings for American conservatism, there is one genuine bright spot. Over the past five years, a group of young and unpredictable rightward-leaning writers has emerged on the scene.
[...]
As a consequence, they are heterodox and hard to label. These writers grew up reading conservative classics — Burke, Hayek, Smith, C.S. Lewis — but have now splayed off in all sorts of quirky ideological directions.
There are dozens of writers I could put in this group, but I’d certainly mention Yuval Levin, Daniel Larison, Will Wilkinson, Julian Sanchez, James Poulos, Megan McArdle, Matt Continetti and, though he’s a tad older, Ramesh Ponnuru.
Ross Douthat and my former assistant, Reihan Salam, are two of the most promising. This pair has just come out with a book called “Grand New Party: How Republicans Can Win the Working Class and Save the American Dream.”
As Steve points out most of this group started out toiling in the wingnut welfare vineyards and Brooks would like us to believe that these shiny empty vessels are not filled with the same old wine but something new! different! causes 15% less cancer! And who knows better about the lives of Sam’s Club Americans than these dazzling think tank urbanites who were taught that power comes from the barrel of a gun (preferably held by yokel and pointed at a brown person) and a paycheck comes in the form of an Olin Foundation grant. Moral scolds and social Darwinists unite! You have nothing to lose. No. Really. You guys never get laid off like people who actually produce goods and services. So theorize away, and, if it doesn’t pan out… blame the implementers who failed to bend reality to your will.
The invisible hand would want it that way.
(Bonus): By the way, I’ll see Steve’s Orwell of The Placemats and raise him James Poulos’ Radiohead Agonistes which elevates wanking to Olympian heights.



22 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
They’ve been intelligently designed.
I actually work at a Sam’s Club (long story, bad local job market) and, while the Members certainly think of themselves as Republicans they would be deeply, deeply insulted to think the GOP sees them as working class — as I gather is the theme of Douthat’s book. They drive Hummers and are Masters of the Universe, as such things are understood in SW Missouri. This book will undoubtedly show up on the club’s shelves, and that will be interesting.
…as opposed to designed intelligent…
Amazing to me, but I don’t think there is any conservatives that understand that there is no such thing as a true ideology for them. Conservatism is reactionary. They have motivation, greed and selfishness, but that’s it. So they simply hate and oppose anything that might interfere with their acquiring wealth and fucking over little people.
I take back the first sentence. I think Churchill grasped this. Oh, and his list of conservative “comers” could only write for wingnuts, no one else would have them.
Megan McArdle? Ramesh Fucking Ponnuru???
If that’s your farm team, it’s going to be a long, frustrating career in the minors.
Can’t say I am familiar with most of these names (thank the gods for small favors), but if they are all in the mold of McArdle and Ponnuru then they must cumulatively have the IQ of a flea. I would not use their writings as toilet paper. Pretty damned grim out there for the wingnut welfare babies.
How on earth could he leave Jonah “Fat Fuck Retard” Goldberg off the list? I confess myself appalled by this oversight.
James Poulos’ Radiohead Agonistes which elevates wanking to Olympian heights
W!T!F! wow. now that’s some serious navel-gazing.
“It may be that we cannot reckon adequately with Radiohead until we reckon in this regard with ourselves.”
“Portents of this mystery seemed to be everywhere, a sky full of comets streaking across suburbia.”
“But rock and roll redemption could only come as escape. In real life, what Radiohead’s bleeding heart boys got instead were proto-indie chicks in premature possession of that other buzzterm of the late ‘90s: issues.”
“For a slightly earlier cohort, characterized by Benjamin Kunkel’s novel Indecision, it was the end of the Cold War that took on uncanny resonances with the personal life of emotion.”
“9/11 notwithstanding, there is no future caught between the two modes of indie abandon, in which irony is meant mostly to hide the hurt. As techno-paranoia and the fast-track spectacle of The Future gripped the imagination ten years ago, today we find agony and anxiety in a condition that seems impossible to escape from for more than stolen minutes at a time. It’s a psychosexual milieu in which satisfaction seems obsolete, mutual manipulation is common currency, and fully contingent commitment defines our interrelationships.”
!!
PfuckingS Roman Hruska would be proud. Well, xcept fer Brooks leaving Jonah off the list. You don’t suppose Brooks charged ‘em all for the mention and Jonah wouldn’t pony? IOKIYAR, ya know. Guess Brooks’ll make it up in post pub bjs, anyway.
Thanks to cleek for sparing the rest of us from clicking that link. A sky full of comets streaking across suburbia? WTF? What a maroon.
Even Bobo has some standards. But I bet lil baby jonah is throwing a tantrum right now.
When I running out to lunch, I switched to Rush Limbaugh and listened to him rant about this very Brooks article. For him, Brooks was not reassuring by coughing up examples of ‘conservatives’ who looked to the New Deal for guidance on anything. Instead, Rush and his ilk see Brooks as the problem, the big-government conservative ‘intelligentsia’ that had brought the GOP to ruin. When Rush argued that the GOP didn’t lose in ‘06 because of the scandals, the Iraq war but because the GOP had left the conservative reservation of small government, that’s when they lost voters.
Hey Bobo, thanks for the list. Now I know the names of writers that will require my BS meter to be set on 11 when I encounter their crap*.
*not that it isn’t always set fairly high, but this list will save me soooooooo much time that could be better spent elsewhere.
Larison will need to change his habits if he’s gonna cash in big like some of those others.
Larison’s response to Brooks’s previous column wasn’t exactly pro-Brooks.
Larison’s a McCain supporter, but not quite the sort of supporter the McCain campaign is going to be touting.
He may not have been sure that Jonah is heterodox. There have been rumors about goats, and well, the less said the better.
No, I have no idea what heterodox means. It sounds elitist, so I’m not even going to look it up.
Poulos is clearly a guy who loves his own wanking most when he’s paid by the word. His hobbyhorse seems to be a fearful bleat for authoritarianism to stop the horrific decay of American culture, only dressed up to look young and hip with a sprinkling of AbFab quotes. His endorsement of a GOP presidential candidate is pretty LOLerrific:
{Note: links below don’t work in Preview, but appear to be properly constructed in the draft, so going for it anyway}
I don’t know much about most of those writers Bobo is crowing about, and have little use for the few I have read (Megan McArdle? Seriously?). I’ll note that Spencer Ackerman mentioned Reihan Salam in a Thursday post, although more as a personal acquaintance than in the role of a critic.
The one name on that list I do have some respect for is Julian Sanchez. Sure, as a libertarian he has some batshit crazy ideas – he’s is, after all, libertarian, although I think more of the social variety. But I would still characterize his basic reporting style as honest and open minded; it’s the subsequent analysis that can get a little nutty on occasion.
FWIW, Sanchez was the guy who first busted John Lott for sockpuppetry (ever hear of “Mary Rosh”?) after noting identical IP numbers from supposedly different online persons. This was well before Aussie blogger Tim Lambert took on the civic duty of tirelessly dogging that sleazy right wing contract shill.
Aim low, Bobo, and you’ll never be disappointed!
Funny, try as I might, I couldn’t find a definition of “heterodox” that included “Something sired by Victor Davis Hanson on Little Green Footballs.”
Man, I gotta say, it sure is fun watching the “serious” conservatives flail about for any thread of hope for their failed ideology. Bobo, let me help you; you and your ilk have ruined the economy, the enviroment, healthcare, and this country’s standing in the world, and the best part is, everyone knows it now. Enjoy the wilderness for the next decade or so. Loser.
Jonah’s already a starter — that’s how bad the current team is.
That Radiohead thing should be in the wanker hall of fame.
We’re not scaremongering
This is really happening
Happening
We’re not scaremongering
This is really happening
Happening
Mobiles quirking
Mobiles chirping
Take the money and run
Take the money and run
Take the money