Following a link from James Wolcott, pointing out that themanwhocreatedmoseswine is every bit as sketchy about literature as he is about film [Ed: Isn't he a novelist and screenwriter? Me: Yes, he is. Ed: Why are we doing parenthetical asides to ourself like Roger does? Me: I don't know. But have I ever mentioned what a droll wit you possess? Ed: Oh, do go on you smooth talker, you...] Anyway, following the link, what to my wondering eyes should appear, but a guest appearance at PeePee Media by Learning Annex Teacher of the Week, Mary Grabar.
For those who are not Grabarheads, may I direct you here and here.
I'll wait....
Hmmmmm...hmmmmm.....trains and boats and planes took you away
But every time I see him I pray
And if my prayer can cross the sea
The trains and the boats and planes
Will bring back you back, back home to me, whoa...oh...
Oh, hi.
So..where were we? Oh yes, Mary Grabar. Her. Yes indeedy. Grabar's stock in trade is bitching about "liberal" academia and tenure and students and women professors who are all conniving bitch feminists who hate Mary's love of the classical canon and... Well, let's just cut to the chase: she can't land a regular gig at a good school and the prospects for tenure somewhere someday is about as likely as a Maxim cover shoot. Oh, and it's everybody else's fault.
But then I thought: what if it isn't something about Mary? What if it is other people's fault? What if the Mary who is trapped in the vicious cycle of semester-to-semester teaching contracts where she is forced to teach Comp 101 to apathetic, if not hostile, slack-jawed juco yokels who don't know Derrida from their derrieres...why, what if that Mary is another Norman Maclean with one great book incubating and growing inside of her; threatening to burst out through her chest like an alien who bleeds acid that melts metal ( your own analogy may vary).
So, with the help of modern technology and this thing that they call the "internets", I "clicked" on one of the "hyperlinks" that I found at Mary's "website" in order to "read" (or "surf" as the kids say) her "short story" Roosters.
An excerpt:
The red and green feathers shimmered in the sun, and I saw that they were roosters. They looked like the figures lining the gift display of the Café Latte, a place to which I was headed, and I walked there with eyes straight ahead.
I was setting down my heavy bag by a little table in the front when the pink-shirted Harley man passed by on the narrow sidewalk on the other side of the window. He didn’t need to in order to get to the Auto Zone next door. Two layers of glass separated us. Then he disappeared.
I walked to the back. I had already had too much coffee that morning, so I ordered a cinnamon steamer from the boy playing a computer game behind the counter.
The three other men, two black and a skinnier version of Harley man stood around the rooster crate lighting up cigarettes.
Café Latte was devoid of the weekday conspirings of retirees and local activists, and of teenagers intertwined on couches, or ear-muffed with headphones pecking away at laptops. I recognized a woman from PTA, who had brought in a basket loaded with bills, cheerfully writing out checks.
—It’s the only way I’ll get them all done at once, she said.
The other customers were two women whose heads bowed intently. They were trying to keep their voices down. It was a conversation I recognized.
It kind of goes on like that, sort of Raymond Carveresque after having been translated from sort of crazy Moonman language, filtered through Mad Libs and then dropped onto the page like pick-up sticks. Which is to say that, while academia may not welcome her with open arms, she may have found her metier cranking out columns for PJ Media.
It has to beat teaching Milton to Raylene and Bubba Bob.....
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
If I had to guess, I’d say James was right in his included question and that Simon Le Poseur conflated Babbit and Dodsworth. An act more of laziness than the one of monumental cluelessness that he favored us with a few days ago in his spec script for ”Bridge On The Red River” starring John McCain.
He was probably distracted, looking out his study window, hoping to see a kid in a Ché t-shirt to yell at.
wow. that’s some clunky writing.
he didn’t need to … what?
Grabar: future ghost writer for Dubya’s memoirs, “I Decidered” perhaps?
but she has a great future as a Horowitz Poster Child:
“I CAN HAZ TENUR?”
But please, NO nude poses with a blue bukkit. I don’t want my eyeballs to explode.
“Roosters” alternate title.
“Because I Can’t Find a Job and Have No Real Creative Skills, I Will Describe the Scene at My Local Starbucks Where I Show Up Every Day in My Lime Housecoat and Bunny Slippers at 11:00. Because I Don’t Have a Job.
Oh Yeah, I Just Bought a Rasberry Scone.”
Pushcart material if I’ve ever seen it.
Re Wolcott link: NO! It must be a generational thing that neo-neocon has Roger Simon on her blogroll because I cannot figure out why he is readable.
Back in the day, I sold cars.
The new Dodge trucks had just been introduced and they took us all to “schools” around the country to learn about the vehicle.
They set up an obstacle course and had each of us drive the truck straight through to get an idea of the punishment the thing could take.
Reading that excerpt from “Roosters” was the English language equivalent of that experience.
WTF? Total non sequitur. Cue Husker Du song: Makes No Sense at All.
That is probably better than the description I could give of my local Starbucks.
“The Starbucks was airy and full of comfortable furniture including large, thick armchairs and blond wood tables. The baristas were friendly and had the appearance of permanent students. The customers came in unhurriedly and often appeared to be in a business meeting or worked assiduously on their laptops. Occasionally a mother with small children appeared there, or even students from the high school. This Starbucks was in the best location in Clayton, near the main bus station, and flanked by additional Starbucks about a mile or so away on either side.”
This is the kind of writing which causes me to pity my colleagues in English who teach freshman comp.
Of course, the late, sainted Glenn Savan would not be likely to set anything in a Starbucks. He would put his scene in Meshugga Cafe or somewhere with actual character.
The Twenty-Seventh City does not strike me as being devoted to local hangouts, but I never finished it.
Speaking as an English lit ABD entering the academic job market this Fall, I look at Ms Grabar and despair: there but for the grace of god go I.
Can anyone here write me a job letter? Thanks.
Somewhere, in the Great Beyond, Hemingway just shot himself again.
Is it just me, or is her writing just not very good?
707
I looked hard for the point of this story, and think that this might be it.
.
I don’t get it, not at all. Selling chickens is exploiting blood-thirst? You could make that case, but she doesn’t. The guys she describes come across as stupid and lazy. (It takes four guys to run this little illegal market?) The only reference to violence is the narrator’s speculation that the man has a gun or two in his glove compartment.
This is a very short story. Every word of it should help create the mood and drive home the point of the story. What is the point of the “he’s not good enough for you” conversation? What might be in the package marked in red and black that the Harley man fetches?
Or is this the big revelation? WARNING! Spoiler Alert!!!
The last paragraph:
WTF? Are we supposed to think this dashed the narrator’s hopes of raising a family with this guy? Is she a privileged progeny who thinks somebody so distasteful couldn’t find a mate?
This story might possibly earn a “C” for a high school freshman class writing assignment…
…if it was graded on a curve.
I just wish she had started with:
“It was a dark and stormy night…”
As someone with a pair of English degrees and ten years of experience as a professional writer, I can say (or type, in this case) the following with some amount of authority:
That was the one of the most absurd, pointless, and just plain God-fucking-awful stories I’ve ever read.
There’s no flow, no sense of place or character, and several sentences that make no sense (as others noted above).
Worse, it goes on and on with this serious, looking-to-be-regal tone, as if she wants to write real literature. The problem is that she lacks the intelligence and/or skill to do it effectively.
The end result is a story that reads like a bad submission into some college freshman story contest … one written by that pathetic emo kid who wants so bad to be some sort of outsider with a message, only to discover she’s really just an ignorant tool with bad fashion sense and a horrific taste in music.
Harsh? Perhaps.
Accurate? Without a doubt.
The mystery to me is how she got this far on the road of life without figuring out that she has no talent. The world wonders too how an enormous state U awards a doctorate to someone that can’t write a composition.
I had always envisioned JUCO English professors as looking like Susan Sarandon in Bull Durham. Imagine my disappointment.
who don’t know Derrida from their derrieres
There’s a difference?
The mystery to me is how she got this far on the road of life without figuring out that she has no talent.
Because all the people who ever tried to tell her were evil liberals trying to keep her down because of her conservative ideas, of course.
Remember, there’s no such thing as conservative incompetence. Never ever. If it weren’t for The Evil Liberal Academic Establishment, she’d have Margaret Atwood’s career.
It appears that Roger’s original post has been disappeared down the memory hole.
I think I get it.
I was setting down my heavy bag by a little table in the front when the pink-shirted Harley man passed by on the narrow sidewalk on the other side of the window. He didn’t need to in order to get to the Auto Zone next door. Two layers of glass separated us. Then he disappeared.
She got cruised by a guy in a pink Harley shirt and it sent her heart a flutter in new and awkward ways.
Who wouldn’t?
Wow. Twenty-six replies and none of us have brought up her sly use of “Roosters” in a story about how Harley guy moistens her loins.
I figured someone would’ve made the “Cocks” comment by now.
Slackers.
The explanation for Mary’s distinctive writing style is fairly simple — it’s an homage to Samuel Beckett. As most serious students of Grabarology know, Mary is Slovenian. Beckett, though Irish, wrote his plays in French, then translated them into English. Inspired by his example, and perhaps hoping to capture some of that same lightning in a bottle, Mary writes her stories in English, then translates them into Slovenian, then back into English.
On a different — or, perhaps, quite similar — note, I can’t wait to see what Our High Lord of the Bassets will do with Jonah’s latest adventures in teh stoopid.
I’ve got my hopes set on some mighty fine snark later today…
Oh yes, yeeeesssssss…
If I were a young slacker I could probably get by with the following comment.
But I’m not, and fuck you anyway.
That writing!!1!: WTF?
Mary should have a fine career writing screenplays for conservative films ala LibertyFilmFest. She might want to try some movie reviews as well.
“The other customers were two women whose heads bowed intently. They were trying to keep their voices down. It was a conversation I recognized.”
It was not a short story I recognized.
She’s not as good as Martin Brest, though to be fair, I like “Gigli” more than most people.
¿Oh, c’mon, no one picked up on this?
I had already had too much coffee that morning, so I ordered a cinnamon steamer from the boy playing a computer game behind the counter.
Tsk, tsk… joo pipples are losing jour edge.
That argument is as old as Americorps. It may be too stale for Tbogg.
Martin Brest made Midnight Run. And Beverly Hills Cop was decent.
Yes, he also made Gigli and Meet Joe Black, but Midnight Run is so great, one can kind of forgive him for his sins.
If Mary Grabar is even close to that level, I’ll eat my entire book collection.
Jonah Goldberg too stale? Surely you jest and tempt fate by comparing him to a mere biscuit. Behold: his sharp mind and wit is no match for those who trust mere facts and reason, he dares to boldly go where no sane pundit (or competent 5-year-old) would otherwise venture, ignoring scorn and ridicule (while attracting both in spades).
Besides, he is totally teh hot, what with the gut, the stubble, and the retro glasses (image originally from here).
wow, that was painful. I love reading good fiction key word being good. this didn’t quite burn my retinas but it came close.
ick
Another EngLit major here, with several Creative Writing courses endured. I’ve seen writing like this, and every CW classmate I’ve known would lie like a rug to keep from hurting her feelings. Although an adult, she writes like a pretentious, naive, empathy-challenged child with not even a hint of creativity or imagination. There would be no point in criticism, constructive or otherwise, because she is beyond help and hope.
She’s also batshit insane, and a teacher. It’s enough to make you believe in demons.
I went to her ‘website’ to check out her other ‘published writings’, but alas–her essay on ‘Feminism’s Legacy: YouTube Catfights’ is no longer available. (By the way, the page with links to her writing is called ‘Type a title for your page here’. Very daring and original.)
In her sort-of defense, English is definitely her second language; she’s Slovenian-born. Of course, she’s been living here since 1959, so you’d think she’d have learned a little bit of the lingo. Also, that doesn’t explain the crazy.
I found the rest of the story.
“–Put your hands up over your head, Michael Murphy. You and your lackeys are under arrest.”
Wow. Just, Wow.
“I stared up and saw the ceiling fan make a slow circle-like motion over my supine body.” ‘Circle-like’. *Not* a circle, but *like* a circle. Physicists, mathematicians and fan-owners, you’ve been warned.
“… the sound of many running footsteps …” Feet, footsteps, whatever. Missed it by *that* much.
“We’ve already got teams searching your meth labs, and they tell me there’s plenty of evidence.” It’s not a crime to have a meth lab unless there’s lots of evidence too.
“There’s not a judge in the county that will convict me on a cockfighting charge.” MarkD at 27, your prayers have been answered.
What with capacious purses, shiny guns and mirrored sunglasses, it appears Ms. Grabar was going to come up short of the required word count for this essay until she remembered Adjectives, the Writer’s Friends.
Honestly, any 45 consecutive words in this minimum opus would be good enough to win the Bulwer-Lytton prize. Let’s do her a favor and submit multiple entries.
Dear god, I think I wrote better prose when I was in 8th grade! That was just…..horribly, embarrassingly….BAD. It was BAD BAD BAD!
Someone please give her tenure so she never feels like she has to earn a living through her writing, okay?
I’m not sure why her writing style reminded me of this. But it did, except that Jack Handey rocks.
“Is there anything more beautiful than a beautiful, beautiful flamingo, flying across in front of a beautiful sunset? And he’s carrying a beautiful rose in his beak, and also he’s carrying a very beautiful painting with his feet. And also, you’re drunk.” — Jack Handey
Please, she can’t focus because she’s too concerned about the problems of America and white civilization. Just who is the ignorant one here?
It’s late in the thread but I’ve just had a breakthrough. Ms. Grabar’s epic is actually a fictionalization of her last faculty meeting.
Think about it. Harley Man (corrupter of youth by drugs) stands in for Faculty Head (corrupter of youth by mandating modernism and excluding Milton). Policewoman represents legitimately outraged authority (aka decent classicists). The innocent victim/bystander/teacher - our Ms. Graber. The bullet that kills the virginal heroine - her Annual Review, no doubt faked by the Faculty Head in an effort to distract everyone from his evil ways.
I mean, otherwise, this whole piece has no meaning at all.
Uh, make that Department Head. Faculty Meeting, Department Head.
Although an adult,
she writesthey behave like a pretentious, naive, empathy-challenged child with not even a hint of creativity or imagination.Corrected for grammatical usage, that sentence now applies to the mentality of all neo-con rethuglicans.