You had to know that someone over at Malkin's Hot Air would manage to take offense when Barack Obama promoted bi-lingualism. I guess it was Special Ed's day at the races:
Barack Obama addressed the issue of official languages yesterday by endorsing one: Spanish. Instead of worrying about immigrants learning English, he told an audience, America should be teaching its children Spanish. Every child should be bilingual, Obama said, but listen to the language he chooses later:
It’s embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe and all we can say is merci beaucoup,
Well, which is it — should we teach them Spanish or French? Maybe we should teach them Chinese, or perhaps Arabic. Immigrants come from around the world to live in America. Perhaps Obama doesn’t realize this, but they don’t all speak Spanish. If our children have to learn foreign languages so that immigrants feel at home here, then we’d better plan on keeping them in school for about 30 years.
Also, Obama’s argument here makes no sense. He’s complaining that Americans don’t speak the native language when we visit Europe, but that we don’t speak the immigrant language when people move to the United States. With that argument, shouldn’t we expect Europeans to speak English when we travel there?
Yeah, hunh? Hunh?
Oh jeez. Here is what Obama said with emphasis on what Ed skimmed over:
You know, I don't understand when people are going around worrying about, "We need to have English- only." They want to pass a law, "We want English-only."
Now, I agree that immigrants should learn English. I agree with that. But understand this. Instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English -- they'll learn English -- you need to make sure your child can speak Spanish. You should be thinking about, how can your child become bilingual? We should have every child speaking more than one language.
You know, it's embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe, and all we can say [is], "Merci beaucoup." Right?
You know, no, I'm serious about this. We should understand that our young people, if you have a foreign language, that is a powerful tool to get a job. You are so much more employable. You can be part of international business. So we should be emphasizing foreign languages in our schools from an early age, because children will actually learn a foreign language easier when they're 5, or 6, or 7 than when they're 46, like me.
Later in his post Ed concedes that Obama is correct about the value of learning a second language (Sez Ed: "...I studied Irish for several years.") but that is long after he has made his point to the average Malkin reader (for whom Murican is the only language if one includes the sub-dialect: "Y'all") and who has the attention span of a hummingbird on meth. And so, to elaborate on an old European Joke:
A person who speaks three languages is tri-lingual
A person who speaks two languages is bi-lingual
A person who speaks one language is American
...and a person who willfully misinterprets them all is Special Ed.
N'est-ce pas?
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
Speaking more than one language… tsk tsk, such an elitist attitude. Like it helps to call it a latte instead of a cup o’ Joe, huh?
Hey, if English was good enough for the Founding Fathers then, danggit, it’s good enough for the rest of us. Besides, notice how those little labels on everything say: “Made in China” — written in good ol’ English? Yup, them Chinese may be making everything up to and including our iPods, but they sure know how to speak to the man in charge; they know, they know… We don’t need no steenkin’ foreign languages.
Hola!
Thus proving that even when conservatives agrees with someone, they must make up an arguenment anyway, just because. It must be so miserable to be them.
Ohayo gozaimasu!
Did not quite a few of the “founding fathers” speak French?
In order to be more like our founding fathers, I propose that candidates must be able to speak French.
Klaatu barada nikto…
or,
The Way Their Brains Stood Still
Honestly, Michelle, how do you expect your children to learn to speak to the help? “No, Consuela! No Comet-o on the counter-o!”
If English was good enough for God and Jesus, it’s good enough for Muricans.
(Sez Ed: “…I studied Irish for several years.”)
Oh, HELL no. Why WHY is it that wingnuts always have this fucked-up Celtic fetish (cf. Daffyduck ab Hugh)? Is it that they want to prove that they’re SMRT, but have trouble finding a language that is neither a dirty mudman tongue or, worse, French?
And I well-nigh guarantee that Ed is lying. Irish is hard. A bottle of Jameson’s says that he picked up some cheap phrasebook at Border’s several years back and it’s been gathering dust next to Atlas Shrugged and Tekwar ever since.
Speaking of which, have you heard about the upcoming remaike of The Day The Earth Stood Still?
Keanu barada nikto.
No, I’m not kidding. I wish I were.
The Day The Earth Stood Stiff
See, even when Obama proposes something everybody agrees with, he’s still wrong. Why? Because he implied that those cheese-eating Europeens do something better than we do here in America, that’s why! Even if those furriner types do speak fourteen languages each, it just goes to show how utterly insignificant their zillion-year-old cultures are compared to the English-speaking U.S. of A.
I am imagining an Irish person snorting over the claim to have “studied Irish.” Perhaps, with benighted souls like the wingnuts, we really should concentrate on helping them master English before we complicate things.
Of course, he’s right: immigrants will learn the language of their adopted country (certain sections of Miami excepted). For Americans to avoid learning a second language means they neither hope nor expect to be part of the larger community. Given the choice, I suppose we should be grateful when/if they bathe and learn a modicum of social skills. One gets the feeling they would resist acquiring those basics if they could.
I am so old that when I was in junior high, they actually tried to make us speak Spanish.
Isn’t that the new Viagra tagline?
The winger’s Celtic fetish makes me feel even more fluorescent blonde than usual, and that’s not a happy thing for me. Sometimes being blonde is a burden…
My Celtic heritage is real; theirs has some sort of weird white supremacist/love of swordplay/ah the good ol’ Dark Ages neurosis attached to it.
I’d be willing to bet that Ms. Malkin speaks a little Tagalog, and that her parents make her use it occasionally.
No, Ed definitely doesn’t pass.
See, I speak Frog.
I assume Keanu is playing Gort?
Which got me to thinking about my experience with the French. Read more’
http://www.tagg-lines.com/2008.....helle.html
That, sir, is an insult to the memory of Lock Martin.
Keanu is playing Klaatu, which is an insult to the memory of Michael Rennie, adding insult to injury. (I hear he was ill that day…)
Hey, Igrew up speaking that sub-dialect and as far as I remember, I’ve never read any Malkin except on this site. I don’t plan to either.
Why in the fuck would anyone want to waste their time there unless they’re looking for snark fodder or unabashed loonacy? The shit of hers that TBogg quotes on this site is reason enough for not wasting time on her. Face it, Malkin, if it weren’t for TBogg, most of us wouldn’t know you existed.
Y’all
Let’s get real here. Most of MalKKKin’s readers can barely (if at all) speak English. No way on God’s earth could they learn another language.
Keanu should actually be playing the role of Eddie, the half-brained delivery boy who Frank uses as a… wait, wrong movie
“I studied Irish WHISKEY for several years.”
Corrected.
And I well-nigh guarantee that Ed is lying. Irish is hard. A bottle of Jameson’s says that he picked up some cheap phrasebook at Border’s several years back and it’s been gathering dust next to Atlas Shrugged and Tekwar ever since.
Be fair: Ed says he studied Irish, not that he learned it. As a hopeless monolingual, I can attest that for some of us years of conning declensions half-heartedly have as little impact on our brains as similar years of stop’n’start aerobic classes have on our ever-expanding abdomens. On the other hand, “Irish” is a great “I’ve studied it for yeeeears” choice, because very few people are able to challenge your dedication with a stream of rapid-fire neoGael, and most of those who can speak English with such thick (albeit charming!)accents as to be nearly incomprehensible to us average American slobs anyway.
Somehow, I doubt that Special Ed has the cúpla focal.
Anyway, Obama’s smart enough to identify that the time to imbue foreign language skills is at the time when kids are picking up their English skills, intuitively and playfully, rather than in a more stifling classroom setting later on. Right now, the Anglosphere (with a few exceptions in Canada) tends to teach foreign languages at exactly the right time for kids to get bored, only to wish later that they’d spent more time paying attention or that they’d been doing activities in Foreign as six-year-olds.
I’m pretty sure everyone I’ve ever met that know more that one language has regretted it. Just a lot of trouble if you ask me.
Just watch Dora the Explorer some day. The kids are being exposed to Spanish in subtle (or not-too-subtle) ways.
The same with classical music: I heard Tchaikowsky as b/g music in a Smurfs cartoon, and of course the collection of Strauss waltzes I got as music-to-work-by could just as well be a collection of Loony Tunes soundtracks.
…theirs has some sort of weird white supremacist…
I think that’s getting pretty close to the mark - I’ve had more than one uncomfortable, unavoidable conversation with Stormfrontesq dickheads who couch their racism in terms of “maintaining white culture”. Since learning German would be too unsubtle even for them, they go for Gaelic, or if they’re especially geeky, Welsh.
Shorter Captain Ed:
“I actually agree with everything Obama said but it’s my job as a conservative blogger to take a couple of words out of context and portray him as an Aztlan loving dark skinned mud baby. If I don’t Michelle Mommy won’t let me play here anymore.”
(I love playing the ’shorter’ game)
That Malkin is a Filipino Hot Air blogger with a sidekick named Captain Ed who derides foreign language skills - is evidence that reality is a bad dream that we make up as we go.
You know, no, I’m serious about this. We should understand that our young people, if you have a foreign language, that is a powerful tool to get a job.
Not once has my abiity to speak fluent Klingon helped me to get a job. Nahron ztu klotlit “fries?”