Econoblogger and incredible simulation of a "health care expert" explains what life is like on Planet McMegan:
Insurance companies already have those undertreatment incentives, but it’s hard to act on them. Right now, people know that their insurance companies would love to provide self-serving "end of life" counseling that would encourage sick people not to waste so much valuable money. But they are limited by, first, competition–an insurance company that tried to do this too blatantly would suffer horrible publicity and ultimately lose business–and second, the threat of lawsuits and/or regulation.
Meanwhile, back on the ranch:
You have no idea what it’s like to be called into a sterile conference room with a hospital administrator you’ve never met before and be told that your mother’s insurance policy will only pay for 30 days in ICU. You can’t imagine what it’s like to be advised that you need to “make some decisions,” like whether your mother should be released “HTD” which is hospital parlance for “home to die,” or if you want to pay out of pocket to keep her in the ICU another week. And when you ask how much that would cost you are given a number so impossibly large that you realize there really are no decisions to make. The decision has been made for you. "Living will" or no, it doesn’t matter. The bank account and the insurance policy have trumped any legal document.
Offer end of life counseling = Insurance PR Armageddon
ICU eviction notice = something you do before you head out for happy hour at El Torito.




36 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
I posted on her site for a while, before her comment section was overrun by Randian dipshits. She’s way over her head. It’s more than a little sad, because she seems like a nice person – she banned me but felt badly about it because she enjoyed my posts. Then she let me back in.
But eventually it just got futile because Steve Sailer fans and libertarian wackaloons took over the comments. She’s playing to her audience, and her audience is composed of douchebags and bigots.
I know Republicanism has given government a bad name, but does anyone really think they are better off with a for-profit bureaucrat who is incentivized to limit/deny your claims? How stupid do you need to be to think you’re better off with this bureaucrat vs. one that simply has to keep the paperwork straight?
You think she is trying to out-stupid her ex-fellow Atlantic’er Douthat?
It’s more than a little sad, because she seems like a nice person
Your definition of nice person must be different than mine.
On a note related to the health care clown halls, Jon Stewart was brilliant tonight in a segment he called “Healther Skelter.”
As someone who has heaped more abuse on Ms. McArdle since her rise to the on-line Atlantic than all but a few, she doesn’t strike me as being intrinsically evil (Or self-aware, but who am I to talk?) but damn, she must be really charming to get away w/ what she types there.
NelsonAlgren (Good nym!) I’d almost pay to read that.
Blog pimpin’.
I have to admit that I’m fascinated by how the right has managed to pretty much exclude all the flagrant insurance abuses from the discussion. You never hear anyone on the right talking about cancelled policies, policy caps and limits, bad-faith denials of coverage, or any of the thousands of scams health insurers use that literally sentence people to death in the name of profit.
But I guess in the Randian Paradise, no business would EVER let you die because they make more money that way.
You think she is trying to out-stupid her ex-fellow Atlantic’er Douthat?
Douchehat got a sex-change? That would explain a lot. Oh, wait, “he”‘d have to have had one to change in the first place.
I think part of the reason they’re having trouble getting more traction with their claims is precisely because so many people have experienced insurance-company issues, or they know someone who has. Ergo, they start making up even wilder shit. (”It’s a thousand-page bill! And Obama is a socialist! so there HAS to be something socialistical in there somewhere!! Or forced death marches by committee!”)
Umm, has she heard of Medicare? I think Medicare is the “insurance company” that handles most end-of-life situations for the elderly. For patients with terminal illnesses other than the elderly, it’s usually the doctors who do the end-of-life counseling, if anyone does it. I think she must be thinking of a health care system on another planet. Hers perhaps.
But they are limited by, first, competition–an insurance company that tried to do this too blatantly would suffer horrible publicity and ultimately lose business–and second, the threat of lawsuits and/or regulation.
This really is the libertarian Mythos in a nutshell, where free market forces always work their magic in theory, real world be damned. Thousands upon thousands of health insurance horror stories and surprise! — not a single company has lost business, not a single CEO has had to sacrifice even one of hundreds of millions and billions in “compensation.” It reminds me of the loons at the Von Mises Institute proving, in theory, why Enron couldn’t possibly have manipulated energy markets in California, even as the company’s traders were being successfully prosecuted for it. It’s the very definition of mysticism to believe so assurededly in realities that transcend perception. Not to mention nuts.
I have never had any use for the Randroid Megan McArdle ever since she once tried to use her stint as payroll temp in some construction company to prove once and for all that unions were no damned good and lord this over others as knowledge that they just didn’t have, sadly.
No rationing here:
But wait, there’s more:
@DennisSGMM, see? The system works. Survival of the fittest. The market adjusts prices and services to meet demand and the ability to pay. Everyone goes home happy because they don’t know those homeless people anyway. And, besides, they want to be homeless and on the street with their fancy-schmancy colostomy bags. Effete, french pansies!
”The threat of regulation”? How’s that working out?
The thing I love about any MM comment section is that sooner or later they start citing their favorite science fiction authors to justify their glibertarian beliefs. Apparently this has replaced the Bible as commonly accepted authority among the glibs.
Megan is the person who slandered the Kidney Foundation over their policy statment without reading it, calls herself an econoblogger but can’t do middle school math or read a tax table or even correctly report a single number in an unemployment report.
We know she’s utterly incompetent. This was simply a declaration of moral & ethical bankruptcy – Why it’s OK to lie about stuff. And her fans lapped it up.
How stupid do you need to be to think you’re better off with this bureaucrat vs. one that simply has to keep the paperwork straight?
well, judging from Bush’s poll numbers, slightly less than 1/3d of the American people fit are, in fact, really that stupid…
Yes, those mentally ill patients had the privilege of being dumped off by the Invisible Van of the Free Market.
Insurance companies are like angry gods. When they kill your family and friends it means you have to worship them more, not less. Otherwise they are likely to kill you too.
McMegan. like all Libertarians, has never lived on or even visited planet earth and so has no conception of what things are like here.
As stupid as you need to be to be a libertarian.
http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/7101
Really hard to consider anyone a libertarian when they threatened to beat up protesters but ol’ 2×4 is just so darn precious!
an insurance company that tried to do this too blatantly would suffer horrible publicity and ultimately lose business
MM is like a secondary character in a science fiction novel or movie, a poor deluded fantasist who sits in a glass chamber with hoses and tubes going into and coming out of her head, who exists in an entirely imaginary world inside her “consciousness.” Sort of like the Matrix, yes, but instead of most of the human race in there with her, it’s just her and her thirty or so fanboys. Then stuff happens to the protagonist, there are explosions and chases, and the glass is shattered and she’s left writhing and gasping on the floor.
This kind of aggressive naivete-bordering-on-ignorance might be forgivable, if not exactly tolerable, in a college freshman. MegMac is about twice that age.
After the first 3 or 4 weeks of Econ 101, when she got to the chapter on market failures, the whole subject lost its simplistic elegance, and it was time to drop the class in favor of “If Jesus fought Superman” arguments in MM’s dorm room.
Trust me, even in freshmen it is intolerable. Unless, of course, you are referring to high school freshmen who still believe in the tooth fairy, Easter bunny, and Santa Claus.
Why? Why the fuck we gotta put up with her? I don’t give a damn if she’s a nice person or if someone wants to have a beer with her. She’s a vapid, hateful twit who needs to STFU.
Indeed.
Her wedding’s going to be interesting. If it’s anything like her car fiasco, she won’t have the license in time, her mother will run into the cake, and she’ll have to fly to Florida to find Suderman.
If McArdle wrote cleverly, or insightfully – or just factually – it might be a different story. She chooses instead to pull stuff out of her ass and commit it to the page in the most vapid prose imaginable. Bitch writes like she got her degree from Facebook U.
Hey! That’s where I got MY degree! I write much better than she does, though.
If she actually put any thought into anything she wrote, it would be a different story.
Then stuff happens to the protagonist, there are explosions and chases, and the glass is shattered and she’s left writhing and gasping on the floor.
If only….
I got my degree at Smartass U.
That assumes that she is capable of actual thought, a fact definitely not in evidence.
Hey! Our team at Wossamatta U whupped yours! Love to have a drink with you sometime and wallow in nostalgia….