David Frum has obviously never smoked pot:
After horrific shootings, we hear calls for stricter regulation of guns. The Tucson shooting should remind us why we regulate marijuana.
Jared Lee Loughner, the man held as the Tucson shooter, has been described by those who know as a “pot smoking loner.”
He had two encounters with the law, one for possession of drug paraphanalia.
We are also learning that Loughner exhibited signs of severe mental illness, very likely schizophrenia.
The connection between marijuana and schizophrenia is both controversial and complicated. The raw association is strong:
* Schizophrenics are twice as likely to smoke marijuana as non-schizophrenics.
* People who smoke marijuana are twice as likely to develop schizophrenia as those who do not smoke.But is correlation causation?
Jared Lee Loughner may or may not have mental health issues, in many ways his rants are similar to a Tea Party speech or possibly an early draft for a post at Reason, but I’d be hard pressed to make the leap from smoking dope to mini-mall shooting spree. Then again, if people are willing to believe that crosshairs are actually the more commonly used “surveyors symbols“, I suppose any belief no matter how far-fetched, desperate and idiotic is as valid as another.




33 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
Sure, Frum. What about the hate talk that unhinged people are stewing in day after day? No connection at all?
Awesome logic. Some pot smokers go nuts and shoot at other people = pot is the cause of all evil. But, Dave, what about all the pot smokers who *don’t* shoot at our congressmen? I’m sure if you ask him, Jared would admit to masturbating, too. So, are you going to assume now that anyone who wanks is a potential killer? What are you going to do with that notion, since it covers, well, everyone? On the other hand, some gun owners go nuts and shoot at other people, but we’re supposed to agree that it’s not the gun’s fault. Sure, everyone who agrees with Sarah Palin is on some level a sociopath, but thankfully not all of them act out on their incepted rage. And I wouldn’t for a moment argue that she needs to be shut up — that’s not how we do things around here. But nobody should be giving her a megaphone or go about validating her insane opinions, because that may lead pot smoking gun owners like Jared to act out on their schizoid notions… If she were called out as a the deranged, hateful bitch that she is, maybe, just maybe, the voices in Jared’s head would have said, “hey, she’s a nutjob just like me.”
Sure, everyone is a potential killer if you look at it the wrong way (that’s why we should all be very, very afraid and let Big Brother snoop everywhere), but the insane leap of faith that “it was hit pot smoking that did it” is unhinged.
Shorter Frum: “Look over there dirty fuckin’ hippies smoking the reefer! They’re the evil ones.”
well, if I recall (and I’m not positive I do completely) when I was seriously smoking weed, I don’t think I had the energy to go out and waste people. My energy was mostly taken up watching reruns of Green Acres.
However, to be serious for a minute can Frum be more of an asshole? I would guess the answer is probably yes, since these people (you know who I mean) always seem to find a way to be more of a jerk tomorrow than the were yesterday. Would that this ability was put to some kind of positive use.
John Wilkes Booth and Jeffrey Dahmer were big drinkers. Maybe we should repeal the 21st Amendment.
The Tucson shooting should remind us why we regulate marijuana.
We don’t regulate marijuana, we prohibit it. Some of us have been asking for it to be merely regulated for years.
That’s very generous of you, Mr. Bogg, although maybe taking the concept of giving-the-benefit-of-the-doubt to an extreme.
By the way, I think the last link (“surveyors symbols”) needs fixin’.
TBogg:
O/T; I don’t know you, but feel I’d recognize you walking down the street, ’cause you’d be the guy with a wheelbarrow at your side to *carry your balls in*.
Awesome work over the last 24 hours.
Pete
P.S. The last guy I saw who had this attribute was Captain Chesley Burnett “Sully” Sullenberger III.
What is he even saying? Some small study in France that doesn’t even seem to say what he thinks it says supplies all the evidence we need for continuing overly harsh drug laws while we ignore far more likely culprits like easy access to guns, over the top violent rhetoric, and shortage of decent mental health care?
David Frum has also obviously seen the movie Reefer Madness.
Rightwing words have no effect on the world whatsoever, but leftwing words can destroy the world. Given that dynamic, I do not know why Frum doesn’t just shut the fuck up since his words will obviously have no impact.
I think he actually lived it, which would explain his transformation from a liberal to a conservative in the 70s.
DrDick, I love you!
Even more telling: they ALL sleep, eat and go to the bathroom (there are THREE MORE THINGS Obama and Hitler have in common, also, too)—so maybe we should outlaw those? Oh yeah….and breathing.
In other news, far right hate mongers simply continue on their far right hate train. The supremely sick and evil Westboro Baptist Church plans to picket and protest the victims’ funerals. Apparently it’s that nine year girl’s own fault for getting shot.
I read “The Birthday Party” by Stanley Alpert. He was a US Attorney who was kidnapped by thugs in New York City and held for a couple of days. Those in charge of watching him spent their time smoking marijuana. Alpert said it made them calm and relaxed. He wondered if he would have survived it they’d been smoking crack or even just drinking. He decided that if he got out alive, he’d make a big donation to NORML. He thinks marijuana saved his life.
Maybe Frum should read this book.
PS–My mother had late-onset schizophrenia and she never smoked a joint in her life. Probably never even saw one. After she got sick, however, she did take up drinking with a pretty heavy hand.
Make it stop! Please, I beg of you, somebody.
I cannot take another stupid conservative.
Btw, have you ever seen David Frum speak? He could use a little weed. The man suffers from hypertension or ADD or something. He’s a jabbering mess.
I’m fairly convinced that the WBC’s hatred is omnidirectional rather than on one side of the spectrum. I mean, they picketed Jerry Falwell for pity’s sake.
As someone else said when they heard they were going to do their preschool “Look at me!” bit again: “I try to avoid wishing harm on others… But sometimes it is really, REALLY fucking hard.”
“>
David Frum writes: Schizophrenics are twice as likely to smoke marijuana as non-schizophrenics, and People who smoke marijuana are twice as likely to develop schizophrenia as those who do not smoke.
Schizophrenics are three times as likely to smoke tobacco as the general public, and adolescent heavy tobacco users are two and a half times as likely to develop schizophrenia as those who do not smoke.
See where I’m going with this? Anybody but a moron– I’m looking at you, Mr Frum– would see that an attempt at self-medication for the pain is going on here.
Phelps is a petty criminal who’s discovered a totally legal scam that garners him attention and funding (e.g., via lawsuits against people who – understandably – raise a hand against one of his minions during their amoral protests).
Here is the Southern Poverty Law Center’s report on Fred Phelps, and here’s the time line they did on his past (up through 2000).
Truly a nasty piece of work.
Westboro’s life work won’t be accomplished until everyone in this world hates their guts. I see no other explanation to this group’s purpose.
And Frum’s column completely misses the point, which is the point of publishing that piece of nonsense.
Such a sad day. Wank-o-lopes like Frump won’t let is go because they are part of the problem.
I wanted to inject some humor. Having trouble embedding at moment.
Anyways, regardless of whether of you believe trying to “love each other is a good statement”. Have a peaceful and safe evening!
: – )
Anyways here is my humor:
http://picasaweb.google.com/croaker999/Why#5560303793206974770
Frum is one of the cautious sorts who thinks we shouldn’t do anything about massive incarceration for possession until more facts are in. No, not those exculpatory facts. Those don’t count. We have to wait for one more half-assed unrepeatable study that implies that maybe it shrinks your appendix, or puts a half-nelson on your flux capacitor gland. Even after they’re refuted, he’ll continue to repeat these reports.
Works for global warming, too.
You beat me to it (I’ve had a couple schizophrenic friends and relatives). Another sad case of confusing causality with correlation.
You know what else seems to be correlated with schizophrenia? Toxoplasmosis. Let’s declare a war on cats.
I may be schizophrenic, but you put David Frum in a room with me, and nobody’s picking me out as the crazy.
No, you would be the most sane person in the room.
No shit! A friend with Tourette’s tried to give up smoking, but his tics only increased to the point where they interfered with his job, so he had to go back to the nicotine.
And then get all his teeth pulled because he’d cracked them over the years trying to control his disorder by clenching them.
TBogg, is there a bag of salted dicks large enough for Mr. Frum? Just askin’
I agree with the more articulate posters that in the last 24 hours you, Jane, EW, DDay have done some real fine work.
Go take an ‘atta boy’ out of the petty cash box.
Fred Phelps, according to that compelte fucking lunatic Hillbuzz, is a leftist and a Democrat. Bet you didn’t know that.
Damn leftists. They’re for gay marriage and they picket funerals carrying signs that say “God hates fags”. Makes perfect sense.
Don’t you know? Cognitive dissonance is the new black.
That was my immediate response as well–self-medication. Good lord. Inflamed rhetoric and guns don’t kill people–it’s the weed, man!
I’m with Lesley. Please make the idiocy stop.
clearly the words refrenced HAVE had some effect. some of you mbl are unable to process irony. good work Frum scar