Charles Lane’s brief claim to fame was a stint at a gone-to-seed once great magazine where, as editor, he discovered that one of his writers was “making shit up”. For years he has traded on this brief moment in the sun like Erik Estrada making a living appearing at car dealership openings. In Lane’s case he landed at sinecure at Fred Hiatt’s Halfway House of Neocon Sophistry (where writers, ironically, “make shit up“) where Charles has toiled in relative obscurity since he’s not good enough for a regularly scheduled column but useful enough in Hiatt’s eyes for an occasional “deep thought” piece… web only, don’cha know.
Yesterday, after recuperating from an exhausting 3 ( three !) posts in two days he pronounced “Meh, on both of your houses” but mostly on the liberal’s house because they have been uncouth and simply awful and this embarrasses him as man who makes a living pretending to be one (a liberal, not a man. This isn’t science fiction):
Yet today in Wisconsin, anger and vilification are once again the order of the day — and the incivility emanates from the progressive end of the spectrum, including, no doubt, many of the same people who blamed right-wing vitriol for creating a climate of violence in Arizona. Union-backed demonstrators, furious at Republican Gov. Scott Walker’s plans for reining in public-sector unions, equate him with Hosni Mubarak and Adolf Hitler, in disgusting mimickry of some Tea Party members’ inflammatory linkage between Obama and the evil dictators of history. (See Photo no. 10 in this gallery) or Photo 13 in this gallery .
Stop to clutch pearls. Maybe retire to the fainting couch and watch a little Lifetime TV.
And, of course, thousands of teachers have abandoned their classrooms to join a boisterous crowd intimidating and obstructing the elected state legislature in Madison — in scenes reminiscent of the Tea Party’s mobbing of Democrats on Capitol Hill during the health-care debate.
This is hypocrisy on an epic scale. I can’t think of a more overwhelming refutation of the claim that incivility is the unique province of the American right — as opposed to what it really is and always has been: a two-way street with both right and left lanes. No wonder so many Americans in the broad center of the political spectrum are turned off by both parties and their sanctimonious “bases.”
High Broderism alert. Break out the “Tip & Reagan sitting in a tree” Sacred Chant of Comity.
One certified progressive, Joe Klein, has had the courage to make the case against the unions’ attempted short-circuiting of democracy, and for Walker’s legislation. Klein brilliantly and succinctly describes the conflict between liberal goals such as quality education and apolitical governance on the one hand, and public-sector unionism as currently practiced on the other.
Joe Klein and other six-figure legacy pundits do not want middle class workers to rise above their station and they should just shut up and stop complaining about it. The last thing American needs is a schoolteacher from Sheboygan Falls making a decent living. The next thing you know, she’ll be putting on airs and acting all hoity-toity and then the seminars at the Aspen Institute will get overcrowded and ruined just like Sundance and, besides, Steve and Cokie don’t have enough place settings for everyone at Sunday brunch.
If the brave Gabrielle Giffords could speak normally, what would she say about these events? I hope she would agree with me: This is a sad moment for liberalism, for the Democratic Party, and, really, for the whole country.
Yes Charles, the peasants are revolting. But in light of your invoking Gabrielle Giffords name for no discernible reason other than an awkward appeal to cheap emotion, they can’t touch you when it comes to being truly revolting.
What a dick.




46 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
“If the brave Gabrielle Giffords could speak normally, what would she say about these events? I hope she would agree with me: This is a sad moment for liberalism, for the Democratic Party, and, really, for the whole country. ”
Disgusting. Just disgusting…
I guess she’d say she would like to cut off your head &
pour a bucket of rancid Santorum down your neck.
which of the below equations is correct:
a) 2 + 2= 5
b) 60,000 peaceful protestors and zero arrests= political assassination and mass murder
c) Charles Lane= a retarded concern troll
Eric Boehlert need to recognize the power of snark, and use it more often.* Somber gravitas is now mostly the province of our lyin’ ass major media reps, who continue to trade in on the once positive reputation of the journalism profession.
I was reminded – maybe it was over at Cole’s place – that this kind of crap isn’t new, e.g., Peggy Noonan “channeling” the recently deceased Paul Wellstone, supposedly looking down at his own funeral in disappointment at the (mis)behavior of the attendees – reports of which were themselves a big pack of lies, as it turned out. [And importantly, lies that were a whole lot easier to propagate at that time, when Internet service was still very limited.]
On the positive side, the attempt to substitute civility for humanity has made Stephen Colbert’s career what it is, and provided him and Jon Stewart a wealth of material. It must make for relatively stress-free days for their writers.
*link (Boehlert’s link is to Steve Benen, NOT to WaPo, fwiw):
If Giffords were able to do so, she would spit in his face.
“Apolitical governance”? Isn’t that an oxymoron?
OT, but also kindasorta not OT (direct link to tweet):
Didn’t know that Joke Line’s progressivosity was “certified”. No doubt Chuckles can explain said certification process, since he’s a certified douchebag.
And hopefully when Giffords is healthy again, the first public thing out of her mouth is an entreaty for Chuck Lane to go fuck himself.
OMG. Love it!
So much for the U.S. leading the world to freedom!/s
The tables have turned. Yesterday twitter had pix of a poster that said something like “Egypt stands with Wisconsin!”
Now, THIS is globalization we can live with.
I think Klein owes Lane dinner and a blow job. I’m fairly sure I’ve never seen Joe’s work described as ‘brilliant and succinct’ and I’m certain the word ‘courageous’ has never been found in the same sentence as his name.
I could say that I’m amazed that two national pundits cannot grasp the basic tenets of democracy, peaceful assembly and what have you. But I’m not. Amazed, that is.
Oh great.
It’s one of the oldest scams in the book, the old “if God could speak to you, he’d say….” or “if Ronald Reagan were still alive, he’d agree that….” followed by a sentiment which by wild coincidence happens to agree with whatever the person speaking wants to convince you of.
Turning it to “If Gabrielle Giffords were able to speak, she’d agree that…” has got to win the award for turning an already dodgy rhetorical trick into something truly despicable. Good going, Chuck.
As GuyInMilwaukee points out in the comments over on First Draft:
I love his misdirection, refuting of the strawman claim that there’s no incivility on the left.
What there isn’t on the left is brandishing of firearms at demonstrations, bragging about willingness to use firearms for political purposes (“We came unarmed – this time”) and overtly violent rhetoric about the blood of tyrants.
That’s before we get into the concept of incivility over an attempt to gut the income of thousands of people versus incivility over idiot-fiction about Obama’s borth certificate, ‘death panels’, getting the government out of my single-payer government health care, and whatever Glenn Beck imagines his toaster is screaming at him this week.
But then, Lane is paid not to understand and to ignore such uncouthness. They’re so uncivil to mention at DC cocktail parties and so detrimental to advancing at the Court of Versailles.
How about “if Reagan was able to twitter-twat”?
Oh, UVP, if you hurry, here‘s a pic of a low-rent blueen Statute of Liberty sign twirler (may have changed by the time you click linky)
What a shitass.
I’m worried. The fact that it is the threat to collective bargaining and not the supposedly exorbitant salaries and benefits of public workers that is causing this uproar seems to be getting increasingly lost in the coverage. The tide of opinion is being moved by these assholes, and pretty soon these unions are going to be good and busted.
And the middle class will continue looking around wondering where the American Dream went. Given Citizens United, political mushiness and media complicity, their “betters” will be able to go on telling them — without meaningful contradiction — that it was stolen by that other bewildered middle class guy in the next yard.
“Yeah, THAT guy. See him? His name is Oliver Twist and he actually dared to ask for more!”
Oh thank you, as long as you understand I only mean that I appreciate you actually remembering that conversation and making the effort, not, you know, for blowing away the last little fluff-like bit of hope for my country that remained in the dryer filter of my psyche.
All gone now.
So, let’s see. Speculators on Wall Street make up bogus ‘securitized instruments’ (worthless crap) with AAA ratings (purchased from ratings agencies) and sell them to pension fund ‘managers’ who get a piece of the action when funds grow. The whole thing turns to shit, which it was in the first place, and the value of the pension fund decreases by billions. Now, the logical conclusion is that:
A) People and firms on Wall Street who were betting against the crap they were selling to State pension funds should go to prison. This is what I, and Matt Taibbi would like to call a ‘sane’ approach. I’d also like to see some percentage of those bilked pension funds payed back, but that’s not going to happen.
B) Pension fund managers who were either in collusion with Wall Street or too dumb to ask questions should not only be fired, but pay a REAL price for their wreckless behavior. Many of these guys got a percentage of the growth, a clear incentive to bet big on risky deals
OR
C) Nurses, firefighters, cops, teachers are crap and are greedy bastards to expect the pension promised them and anyway, it’s obviously ALL THEIR FAULT that their retirement went into the crapper.
Clearly the answer is C if you are a Republican or an asshole like Joe Klein.
Joe Klein and Charles Lane can eat shit and die. And all the wingers with agents who ‘negotiate their salaries’, (and if they don’t get what they want, they threaten to take their dollies and go home, you know…strike)…Glenn Beck, O’Reilly, Limbaugh, etc. can eat shit and die. I want a genuine uprising where the people who are really getting screwed turn on these wingers like rabid dogs…or Egyptians.
Sorry I could help….
While Chuckles Lane is apparently part of the aerial attack on unions, there are also sewer rats making a subterranean approach. Take the case of Mark Williams, whose racism got him booted by the teatards – yes, it was that bad (background on Mr. Williams here, here, and many other places).
Williams’ plan is to infiltrate campaigns organized to seek volunteers to support the WI pro-worker protests. As reported by MoJo’s Andy Kroll (among others):
Mr. Williams says he plans to show up at some SEIU shindig in Sacramento on Tuesday at 5:30pm. He seems to have a penchant for falling on his face outside of any tightly controlled wingnut-friendly environment, so he may not be worth worrying about too much, as an individual.
However, there are folks who are very good at this sort of thing, so I hope various union supporters remember what happened to ACORN and Shirley Sherrod, and what is currently being attempted against Planned Parenthood (e.g., via Lila whatsherface, trying to follow in the footsteps of aspiring rapist James ‘Pimp’ O’Keefe).
the big players in the local media are making some minor mention of this…between their near constant stream of republican talking points.
http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/article_eb54a3dc-3ca3-11e0-b5ab-001cc4c002e0.html
This is a high volume popular place and when I went by yesterday it was packed like a sardine can and a line down half the block. They also do a good job of using local product, so those calls are relly helping the local community too. Thank you!
outrageoftheday ftw. You are almost as brilliant and succinct as Joe Klein.
So the Koch brothers = not privileged.
3rd grade teacher = privileged.
Wrap you brain around that one.
I would hope the brave Gabby Giffords will at some point respond to using her name to peddle such tripe, like demanding a retraction and an apology.
Maybe she’d offer him a one-way ride on a space shuttle to Pleiades or wherever it is that these creeple came from 6,000 years ago…two tickets..one for Sarah too.
Gotta wrap a tea bag around that one because my brain just won’t.
Is Lane trying for the lead in Maureen Dowd’s next column?
Maybe since Scott Walker can’t be recalled before 2012, Wisconsinites should look at recalling Rethuglican legislators who are pushing his tyranny….
TBogg, great writing. Enjoyed reading it. I’m not hot on the Wisconsin issue, figuring that as in Egypt the locals can handle it w/o any input from me, and Lane doesn’t interest me, but you powerfully describe a situation that interests you. For Lane it’s a devastating put-down. Three and out.
Language can be a powerful weapon (look what O did with it) and you are well armed. Who’s next on your dance-card?
I don’t recall any liberals becoming indignant about the TEA party or opponents of health care reform using their first amendment rights. In fact, I recall many instances of liberal affirming the first amendment rights of the those groups. What liberals became angry about was when those groups tried to prevent the other side from being heard and when they threatened or used violence.
Those are distinctions conservatives fail to make.
nah, There’s no oxy in it.
Those are distinctionsconservatives failto make.More succinct. You don’t need all those extra words spread liberally around.
Surely the Coneheads would object to that particular “containment” plan?
Mostly I recall laughing at them. Not at the exercise of their first amendment rights, but at the hilarious amalgam of tricornes and electric scooters.
You forgot the wonderful misspelled signs.
Winning strategy for wingnuts. Their plan is to put the U.S. in fourth world (you know, the one to the far bottom of the poorest African country).
Ever notice how these asshats always break out someone that it’s impossible to get an opinion from as their backup? Mysterious non-demographics and victims who’s inability to communicate for themselves obviously means any dipwad with a keyboard is perfectly justified in projecting whatever nonsense they want on the victim’s person.
Indeed. What a dick.
Nitpicking:
their wreckless behavior
does not mean what you think.
You want
their reckless behavior
Saw that on the tube this morning and was waiting for the corporate news spigot to challenge him, you know old whatisname…but he didn’t…went back to reality and turned off the tube.Too many clowns think they are wise men.
Right. Sorry. Once one gets typing, one often just lets the fingers fly without thinking. At least I haven’t substituted ‘than’ for ‘then’. Now that drives me nuts.
Dude, fuck ‘em all the fucking fucks.
Enuff of the niceties . . . they suck, we don’t, end of story.
Don’t waste the white space . . . save it to support Madison, WI.
N we the people.
It’s days, months, years like this I wonder if we shouldn’t bring back dueling. It might help keep the lies down. Not pistols, but swords. Probably less fatal, though…
I mean, really, do you think Beck, O’Reilly, Limbaugh, ad nauseam would lie quite so much if they thought someone — anyone — could walk up to them on the street and challenge their “honor” to a duel at dawn. They’d have to hide out in their houses 24/7, and that wouldn’t play well with the “manly” teabag crowd.
Rep. Giffords’ astronaut husband should take a poke at Lane. It’d be worth the misdemeanor fine. Though the Right would faint at the “violence.”
Locally supplied goods at Ian’s?
UNITED DAIRY FARMERS ARE UNION FARMERS.
This is bill o’reilly reporting from an undisclosed location…
Well you see liberals are just spineless socialists who want to take away our gu…oh shit the liberal dueling league caught up to me, we won’t be on the air for another week, please enjoy reruns until I can continue reporting on the left wing pussies…while hiding under my desk hoping they don’t catch me.
I’m all for the guys on the front lines; but this still cracks me to this day
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3mw49mk_x0
This is a sad moment for liberalism, for the Democratic Party, and, really, for the whole country.
But it is saddest of all for Charles Lane. It requires stunning dickishness to imply you speak for Gabrielle Giffords who is, after all, a Democrat you stupid shit.
If Giffords could speak, she’d say “Buy Axolotl Brand Veeblefetzers! They’re the finest veeblefetzers money can buy!!” That’s what she’d say.
The equivalency thing is really important these days. We must believe that the two sides are both at fault, to the exact same degree, or else the worst side won’t wriggle off the hook.