
Over the weekend David Barstow of the New York Times went BOOM on Wal-Mart for being a very naughty evil global retail hegemony and bribing their way into the hearts and minds of our brown neighbors to the south:
Wal-Mart dispatched investigators to Mexico City, and within days they unearthed evidence of widespread bribery. They found a paper trail of hundreds of suspect payments totaling more than $24 million. They also found documents showing that Wal-Mart de Mexico’s top executives not only knew about the payments, but had taken steps to conceal them from Wal-Mart’s headquarters in Bentonville, Ark. In a confidential report to his superiors, Wal-Mart’s lead investigator, a former F.B.I. special agent, summed up their initial findings this way: “There is reasonable suspicion to believe that Mexican and USA laws have been violated.”
The lead investigator recommended that Wal-Mart expand the investigation.
Instead, an examination by The New York Times found, Wal-Mart’s leaders shut it down.
Neither American nor Mexican law enforcement officials were notified. None of Wal-Mart de Mexico’s leaders were disciplined. Indeed, its chief executive, Eduardo Castro-Wright, identified by the former executive as the driving force behind years of bribery, was promoted to vice chairman of Wal-Mart in 2008. Until this article, the allegations and Wal-Mart’s investigation had never been publicly disclosed.
But The Times’s examination uncovered a prolonged struggle at the highest levels of Wal-Mart, a struggle that pitted the company’s much publicized commitment to the highest moral and ethical standards against its relentless pursuit of growth.
[...]
In one meeting where the bribery case was discussed, H. Lee Scott Jr., then Wal-Mart’s chief executive, rebuked internal investigators for being overly aggressive. [my emphasis.. you'll see why later] Days later, records show, Wal-Mart’s top lawyer arranged to ship the internal investigators’ files on the case to Mexico City. Primary responsibility for the investigation was then given to the general counsel of Wal-Mart de Mexico — a remarkable choice since the same general counsel was alleged to have authorized bribes.
The general counsel promptly exonerated his fellow Wal-Mart de Mexico executives.
Since then Wal-Mart has been in damage control mode as they have watched their stock prices fall … just like their prices!:
Wal-Mart Stores Inc said on Tuesday it has appointed a global officer to oversee compliance with a U.S. law that forbids bribes to foreign officials as it grapples with a bribery scandal that has led to more than $10 billion being cut from its market value.
The move is one of the steps the world’s largest retailer has taken in the past year to manage issues related to the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA), a 1970s law that forbids bribing foreign officials.
Wal-Mart shares closed 3 percent lower, adding to declines from Monday that wiped $10 billion from the company’s market value.
Wal-Mart spokesman David Tovar declined to say when the post was created or who was named to fill it. The person appointed will report to the general counsel for Wal-Mart’s international unit.
Well, that worked out so well before.
Moving further on down the journalism food chain, we find the Combat Journalists at the Washington Free Bacon straining and heaving and grunting and wheezing while trying to make this all about President Barack “I Blame” Obama under the headline; Buffett Call Pays Off (Mexicans).
Liberal billionaire Warren Buffett’s investment firm initiated a considerable stake in Wal-Mart as the retail company was engaged in “a campaign of bribery to win market dominance” in Mexico.
Berkshire Hathaway purchased nearly 19 million shares of Wal-Mart stock in the second and third quarters of 2005, right around the time that company officials first learned of massive bribery scandal in Mexico, according to a New York Times report published over the weekend.
[...]
As of Dec. 31, 2011, Buffett’s firm was the fourth-largest institutional investor in the company, owning close to 40 million shares worth more than $2.3 billion.
Buffett, a devout supporter of President Obama and the inspiration behind the so-called Buffett Rule to raise taxes on the super-wealthy, has a history of profiting from the administration’s policies.
Buffett has personally contributed $5,000 to Obama this election cycle, while Berkshire Hathaway has given $30,800 to the Democratic National Committee.
The Free Bacon’s point, and I believe they think they have one, is that Warren Buffett bought a whole bunch of Wal-Mart stock while Wal-Mart executives were double-secretly breaking a whole bunch of laws that has now resulted in a $10 billion loss in market value to say nothing about the ginormous fines that will inevitably face in both the United States and Mexico… and Warren Buffett did this because … um …. Warren Buffett is really really shrewd that way. Also, Obama bad.
Well played, Bacon.
Slowly rising up from the depths of the journalistic ocean where the Free Bacon fights it out on a daily basis with its fellow bottom-feeders (the TuckerCarlsingPost and Andrew Breitbart’s Big Blocked Arteries) for the choicest muck through which to rake, Politico also plays Six Degrees of Wal-Mart Shame only this time it points towards The Man Who Would Save Us All… yeah, that guy – Mittens “Mitt” McMittenMitten:
A Democratic source emails with an interesting tidbit linking Romneyworld to the Wal-Mart coverup exposed by the New York Times.
Turns out, the former Wal-Mart CEO who helped shut down an investigation of bribery by store officials in Mexico is an operating partner at a private equity fund started by Mitt Romney, his eldest son and his campaign finance director.
H. Lee Scott Jr. became an operating partner at the Romney fund, Solamere Capital, eight months after he left Wal-Mart in 2009. Solamere’s partners and investors include major Romney campaign donors and staffers. Romney was a senior adviser and the first investor in the fund, putting up $10 million.
The Times reported that Scott rebuked internal investigators for being too agressive (sic) in uncovering bribery by store officials in Mexico. The investigators allegedly found credible evidence that some $24 million in bribes allowed the store to dominate the market in Mexico, but Scott and others hushed up the investigation until the Times disclosed it Sunday.
The link was first reported by the Boston Globe, where I did some extensive reporting on the $250 million private equity fund last fall. Romney resigned from his role in advising the fund when he announced his run for president, but his son and his campaign finance director, Spencer Zwick, remain managing partners. Scott is still an operating partner.
[...]
Whether the Obama campaign can successfully ding Romney through the link to the Wal-Mart scandal remains to be seen. There is no evidence that the Romney fund itself was involved in the coverup. But the link jibes with the campaign’s previous allegations that Romney was an unprincipled private equity executive.
The Romney campaign declined to comment.
We expect their comment to be: “Uh….um…. Obama eats dawg!… harharharhar. Dog! LOL!! High five! Awesome. Heh… yeah. That’s funny.”
Because that’s all they’ve got lately.




45 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
I thought they already had someone with this responsibility, the CEO. Maybe the CEO just got confused as to whether he was supposed to oversee forbidding bribes versus overseeing bribes.
So nice to see that the evilness that is WalMart is now infecting it to the core. Their aggressive, predatory and now illegal business model is shown to be the sham that it really is.
Gives a whole new vision to ‘The Waltons’- the whole clan shouting out ‘Good night!’ To each other from different cells on the different ranges in the joint.
And they expect the Mexicans to take a hit for the greedy gazpachos? Yo, Warren, fuck a buncha WalMart stock, how’s about popcorn futures?
“Obama eats dawg!”
No, no, I’m pretty sure we’re beyond that. It started that way, then it quickly changed to “ate a dog,” and now I’m pretty sure they’re moving on to “eats dogs.”
From there it’ll be “He’ll eat YOUR dog!” “He’s eating MY dog right now!” “He likes to eat dogs while smelling farts.”
After that, I’ll let you guess. Don’t err on the side of maturity and you’ll be okay.
H. Lee Scott Jr is Solamere’s Saruman.
This is extremely good news for John McCain.
Gee, an ethical question with Mitt and his business practices? I’m shocked. Mitt obviously had no principles in business, so why would we think he has them in his politics? Actually, given the Republican idea of running government like business, I think ethics and principles are detriments in applying their “solutions” to our government.
I’m sure none of the Mexican Romney cousins were any of the bribed officials. Something like this could never be used to funnel money to relatives of executives or board members.
Donde esta el dinero?
That’s all baby shit compared to the harvested child organs, mind-blowing drugs and man-gina’s (for the progressive’s progressives) flowing north through Obama’s ginormous smuggling pipeline from Mexico.
We need a badass new sheriff in town!
Romney/Swamploggers 2012!
I knew that “Once this thing hits Walmart…” tag had versatility, but who could have imagined that a time would come when it would be so perfectly applicable?
I blame Snowshoe Snooki.
This whole thing is being blown way out of proportion. I mean who among us at one time or other in their life hasn’t offered $24 million in bribes?
Uh, its GABACHOS– unless you were referring to those greedy cold tomato soups…
Genius.
Mittens can try and top this….
But he’ll only look like this.
The sun rises.
People have died at sunrise.
It’s Obama’s fault.
On both counts.
IT IS ALWAYS THE CASE that the people on top provide a framework for ambition and most frequently allow those who are willing to cheat to fill those roles. By default, cheating is the winning gambit when it comes to competing and effortlessness. Just consider the game theory of this scenario. It NEVER FAILS. NEVER.
And you can always tell. Either a business builds local lives and standards or it builds itself and its owers. It’s such an easy tell. So easy.
If competition is not for FUN, then it is a DEATH MATCH. No gray area. One way or the other. enjoy.
Reeducation camps to open this fall. Guess whats on the menu…
“Buffett has personally contributed $5,000 to Obama this election cycle”
Good Lord! Quite the scoop there, FB. $5K!!! Buffett owns Obama, bitchez.
“Andrew Breitbart’s Big Blocked Arteries.” Heh, made me laugh. Carry on.
I price shop assiduously and I’m here to tell you that Walmart rarely has the best prices. The company is proof, if anyone needed it, that repeating something many, many, many times works. Twenty-four million in bribes and can’t pay workers a decent wage.
I used to live in Argentina. Locals told me all about how Walmart colluded with the Menem Government to buy cheap, well-ubicated real estate (i.e. former detention centers where dissidents were tortured and disappeared).
In exchange for the sweet deal, it appears Walmart agreed not to dig too deep when building the stores, you know, in order not to unearth the remains buried on site.
Culminating in;
Obama is going to take away your dog’s gun and then make him buy insurance! Then a death panel will put your dog down! And then he’ll eat him using a sickle and hammer!
I guffawed at that myself (and I try to avoid guffawing at work).
Just when you think the well’s gone dry….
Romney/Barney Fife 2012!
Ahhh, the Goldberg Variation!
A couple more quotes:
“Wal-Mart has also done its part to support the Democratic Party, recently donating $50,000 worth of gift cards to the host committee for the Democratic National Convention.”
“Obama will deliver his convention acceptance speech at Bank of America Stadium.”
The dots are connected!
We going to get the imperial columns again?
$24 million cash money in bribes? Wonder how all those local governments feel now about how they let Wal-Mart move into their town and destroy their Main Street businesses by just offering them a new firetruck?
Chumps.
This Andrew Stiles buffoon @ the birdcage bedding mill known at the Free Beacon just launched himself into the stratosphere of stupid with his wretched attempt at an expose on Buffetts Wal-Mart investment – a place of rarified, stupid air occupied intermittely by the Dirigible of Drivel and always by Glenn Reynolds and anyone who writes for Renew America.
The logical conclusion of Stiles article was that Buffett knowingly bought shares in Walmart while they were making bribes to the Mexican government – which beyond obvious violations insider trading rules, infers that Buffett surmised that this news wouldnt someday hit the street, sooner or later.
Why yes, Andrew, buying high and selling low is exactly how Buffett has gotten to be a billionaire.
No wonder these combat
avoidersjournalists work at this laughable excuse of a newspaper – no one else could possibly employ them.Oh come on guys….. bribery in Mexico? That’s the national pastime. Nothing gets done down there unless somebody gets a bribe. And I’m talkin mucho denero! I don’t want to defend Walmart, but, IF the USA is gonna be a player on the internatinal soccer field that IS world commerce, big money is gonna HAVE to end up in the referree’s lockers somehow.
I was a travel agent for 28 years and was visiting Mexico as a guest of the tourist department. We took a tour through the wealthiest neighborhood in Mexico City. The guide said, “Theese is the house of the chief of police. Theese house cost $4 million US dollars. The chief of police makes $59,000 US dollars per year. He must have had his cousin lay the carpet for free.”
My wife, a physician, sued Wal-Mart after a nasty slip and fall where they clearly hadn’t cleaned an aisle of some powdery substance. Fortunately I work for a law firm that took the case for a greatly reduced fee (we don’t normally do plaintiff’s work). It took forever, and she was pretty severely injured, but she prevailed.
They fight every case, tooth and nail. They paid for a private investigator to follow and film her to see if she could “lift” something. Crap assholes.
In another instance, there were two cases pending in Federal Court where in one state the Waltons were denying having a document in the discovery process, when the very same document was being provided to a Texas court. They’re beyond contempt.
I’ll *never* get the hang of this Messikin Spanglish! Too much Boricua-speak confuses me. Nearly four years in Colorado, and I still struggle w/ MexiSpanglish and its odd cadences and slang words. It was so much easier in Florida; Boricua, Cubanese and then everything else Hispanico.
I blame Obama. Dammit.
I wish Wal-Mart could be sued for all kinds of its gross nuisance. I was in Mexico City when the first one opened, with its 75 cash registers in waiting. Then I was traveling through rural Mexico over 15 years later.
Mexico never had, nor needed, trash pick-up services, re-cycling centers, corporate trash compactors and incinerators, or giant land-fills. Their economy did not contain built in obsolescence. Anyone lucky enough to have something they did not need could throw it out the window along the road. Because somebody else does need it.
But 15 years after Wal-Mart opened, the once-pristine countryside was covered with their fucking plastic bags. Scavenger people can only use so many of them.
I was thinking that, too. And I wonder (and have done so for many years) about similar commercial ventures in many countries across the globe, such as India, Russia & China.
I happened to have dinner one time with a very select group of high flyer financial attorney guru types. They were moaning and groaning about the unceasing bribery/baksheesh it took to do the simplest thing in India. Having lived for a period of time in India (with all due respect, as I very much enjoyed my time there), I could well understand what they were going through.
But hey: if someone wants to bust the chops of WalMart for bribery in Mexico, who am I to argue? Couldn’t have happened to a more “deserving” corporation.
That said, trying to connect this to Buffett & Obama somehow is just plain ridiculous. I have my own issues with Obama (I draw a veil over them for now), but that’s teh stooopit.
I like the photo of the “Wall Martian” accompanying the article.
In case people are not familiar with the statue, it is part of Mexican sculptor/artist Sergio Bustamante’s work entitled “In Search of Reason.” The installation includes two more triangle-headed people climbing a 60 foot ladder.
http://publicheart.wordpress.com/2008/11/07/in-search-of-reason/
It is installed on the boardwalk (malecon) of the beach in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico along with bronze sculptures by many other artists.
Heh heh, I grew up poor in the CA wine country and live in New Mexico now. When I used my limited latin spanish here, the locals looked at me like I had 3 heads. Regional dialects are more prevalent in Spanish than Americans have accents,I suppose. Personally,gazpacho makes me greedy–for more!
“I’m shocked. Shocked to find that bribery is going on in here.” “Your envelope , sir.”
Indeed, I don’t condone any bribery. OTOH, in many cultures it IS the norm.
Actually, it is HERE too, we just call it “campaign finance” and “consulting fees”.
Ral “pot-kettle” moment huh???
I don’t like it either, but when living in India, I paid a lot (for me) of baksheesh to get some stuff done (mainly for some locals I knew at the time). Petty stuff, but bribery nonetheless. It was THE way business was done there. Couldn’t get it done otherwise.
Poss. the same for this dealio with WalMart in Mexico??
Ya gotta know it’s going on world-wide. As I stated, I know attorneys who’ve paid bribes in other countries… believe me, conservatives that they were, they didn’t like it one iota. But that’s the way things were done.
Again, to somehow tie this to Warren Buffett and Obama is the height of idiocy, but when did a little idiocy ever stop a conservative from behaving like an idiot???
These are the real Wal-Martians. Way scarier than the little triangular guy.
http://www.peopleofwalmart.com/photos/
Back in the 80′s/90′s Northrop was nailed for bribing Japanese Government officials. The Chairman of the Board and many of the Top Executives were fired.
But, that may have only happened because Boeing or General Dynamics made it happen.
I hope I don’t sound like a naif, or even worse, someone who buys things at Wal-Mart, but what exactly is the big deal here? In some countries, bribery is simply part of the cost of doing business. No one will be happier than I if they fall on their asses, but over this?
Read all about it here: http://theshadowworld.com/
WalMart’s bribe’s in Mexico compared to defense industry “bids”, especially concerning Saudi Arabia where the oil/weapons/cash play put billions of dollars into the pocket of a certain Prince and Friend of the Bushes, are pretty tame…
I blame Obama for all of that….
I know of one place that demanded, and got, a W*lM*rt store when W*lM*rt decided it was a good location for a ‘distribution center’ (read central warehouse, with lots of truck drivers, some even local). They still lost a lot of local businesses (and as soon as those businesses closed, the prices went up).
Hey Itchy, better to blaim Mittens & almost Governor Meg Whitman. Solamere was/is a place to keep an eye on neer do well son-o-Meg under the watchful and sober eye of Tagg so that the children of wealth and privilege stay out of the “lime light” and off the police log of “incidents.”
Check Gawker or, better still, Calbuzz for the high-larious details.
Nepotism. Bitchez. Get some!