Dull human anagram Reince Priebus on last Sunday’s George Stephanopoulos Muppet Hour:
PRIEBUS: George, here’s what I think. I think this president has got a problem with the American dream. You know, when I grew up — and I know that both Republicans and Democrats listening to this right now agree with this — when I grew up, in a great place called Kenosha, Wisconsin, my dad was a union electrician, my mom was a realtor. We drove around town, and when my parents and we drove past a beautiful house on the corner, my parents didn’t point at the house and say, hey, look at this lousy people in this beautiful house. Look at this guy and his new Corvette. My dad did probably the same thing your dad did and a lot of dads out there. He turned around, and he said, listen, pal, if you work hard and you go to school, mom and dad, we hope you live in that house. We hope it’s two times bigger than that house. That’s the American dream. And this idea that we’re spending all of our time just killing people because they live the American dream and made something out of nothing and made money — I mean, this is crazy talk. And I just think we need to get back to the issues.
Duller android cypher Mitt Romney playing back a tape-loop of what future hired help Marco Rubio supposedly once told him:
“[Rubio] said something that will stay with me a long time,” Romney said at a recent rally in Council Bluffs, Iowa. “He said when I was a boy living poor in this country with my family, we saw some other homes, great big homes and fancy cars. He said, ‘I never heard my parents say why can’t we have what they have. Instead my parents said aren’t we lucky to live in a country where with education and hard work, there’s a shot we have of earning that ourselves.’ That’s the nature of America. We’re the land of opportunity.”
Remarkably similar stories, dont’cha think? Brothers from another talking point mother?
Yeah, actually my dad didn’t do that.
When I was a kid, my dad and his brothers had a dry cleaning business and, back in those days, they actually used to deliver dry cleaning to their customers homes. It sounds weird now but it’s true. My dad, being the youngest, used to make most of the deliveries (in fact, we were so poor that the delivery panel truck was also the family car) and he used to tell us how, when he went to deliver dry cleaning to the swells up the hill in La Jolla, often people would leave a note on the door or the gate asking him to leave their clothes because they wouldn’t be home. In those days most people would pay upon delivery, so my dad would knock on the door or ring the house anyway in an attempt to get paid which, at the time, was probably a couple of bucks tops back in those golden days when dimes and nickels weren’t just useless pocket weight. After getting no answer, my dad would leave the clothes to avoid a call to the shop wondering why they hadn’t been delivered which could only mean yet another trip back up the hill. More than a few times, after getting back in the truck, he would look back at the house only to see the curtains move because the occupants were checking to see if he had gone and whether it was safe to come out and collect their belongings.
All of this, of course, to get out of paying a $1.50 for services rendered which, by the way, the customer would invariably dispute the next time they dropped their clothes off if they weren’t outright trying get out of paying because of too much starch or maybe a missing button.
He used to tell us all about it over dinner.
But what my dad didn’t tell us was that those rich people who lived in those nice houses were the real hard workers in the world (unlike himself and his brothers) and if we worked as hard as those wealthy folks we could be just like them and live in a nice house, and not a $35 a month apartment, and we could drive a big car that we actually owned and maybe even someday have a color TV. Because, even at a very young age and before we had the appropriate words to describe them, he didn’t need to tell us what we instinctively knew about these people and how they got where they were.
They were assholes.
The kind of assholes who would try to screw some guy out of a couple of bucks because he was just a common working man with a family and he didn’t make his money the old fashioned way.
By inheriting it.
So Reince Preibus and Marco Rubio can take their remarkably similar Dreams My Father Sold Me stories and blow it out their asses. That starry-eyed pie in the sky bullshit doesn’t sell any better now than it did back then. Save it for the rubes at the Americans For Prosperity and Freedomworks rallies.
Those dumbasses will believe anything for the price of a balloon…





52 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
In the 70s and 80s my mother worked 8-10 hours a week as domestic help for a rich couple in Boston.
She was treated well by them and when the woman she worked for found out I was an avid reader she sent along numerous books to me as gifts.
Recently that woman died and my mother was contacted by an attorney who told her she’d been granted a $1000 bequest as thanks for her work.
Somehow I doubt the Romneys have made any such arrangements.
There are decent rich people in this world but then there are cannibals like Willard.
gGoogle the relatable Romney meme.its amusing. e g i know what its like to lose your home-I’ve forgotten where my fourth one is.
Ya know Prince Rebus, the “American Dream” like “Manifest Destiny” before it is just another way the wealthy and their toadies in this country have tried to shape the language to give
God’sthemselves permission to be lying, thieving, slack-jawed Kochsuckers.For a while they were trying the ‘your just jealous’ line. Guess that didn’t work.
“I know what its like to lose your home-I’ve forgotten where my fourth one is.”
“For Pete’s sake! I have people that have people that keep track of stuff like that! Or I could, if you could get good help in this country.”
I had a paper route as a kid in the 80s. 4 miles, 40 customers, morning delivery in upstate lake-effect snow NY. I bought the papers for 19.25 cents and collected 25 for them (80 cents,dollar for sunday), collection being a separate trip once a week in the afternoon. Everyone says paper routes give kids character and teaches them lessons. The lesson I learned is that adults will screw over a 12 year-old for $2.50. My best customer was a bar.
Here’s another reason why the story is total bullshit. When I was a kid, managers and CEOs made more money than the average line worker, but nothing like it is today. Now you’ve got people who sit around all day pushing numbers around a spreadsheet, making 100 times what an average person earns. The differential has become obscene.
And not for nothing, but who could have guessed that someone with the name of “Reince Priebus” would be a total asshole?
Trying to create a new talking point ala the “People moved to this country and tried very hard to learn everything they could about America especially the language.”
Listen to the Jelly Roll tapes from the Library of Congress(No, really, listen to them. Its’ amazing how fantastic a story teller and teacher of history this man was)One part he mentions how, at the turn of the last century in New Orleans(I think it was N.O.) there were a lot of immigrants who made no effort to learn English and weren’t ever going to try. And from my blue collar mom I never heard this speech rather I would have gathered that the rich were just as everyone here mentions, cheap arrogant bastards.
With a name like Reince Priebus (jesus, I had to look back up to spell it correctly), you know he had to have gotten the shit kicked out of him every day at achool. Lots of anger and envy issues here, me thinks.
The man who would be president proudly declares that he and his family give as little as possible to support the nation that has given so much freedom and safety.
Fucker has a lot more to protect than I ever will, but my effective tax rate is nearly double than what he paid last year on his nice $21 million retirement income.
I think the Republicans’ next move should be to attack that crazy, anti-Christian cult Harry Reid belongs to.
Tbogg, your snark the last 24 hours has been very shrill with an extra tasty, spicy bite. I like it.
My question is this: What happened? Did the pups pee on your iPod?
Imperial conquest, check
Profitable marriage, check (Good news for John McCain)
Organized looting, check
“Forward into the past!”
Firesign Theater
Brilliant! Some anagrams:
Beer, urine, pics.
Brinier cup, see?
Superb ice rein.
Rue nib pierces.
Ripe bi-censure.
…and my favorite, Nice ripe rubes, which describes his job as head of the RNC.
Reince Priebus & other rightwing lackeys, including legacy twit favorite, L’il Luke Russert, are all duly trotting out the good old days meme, as they vainly try to hump Ronnie Ray-gunz coffin yet one more time… with feeling!
Even my most brainwashed of Tundra Trash Couger worshipping rightwing nutjob Glenn Beck-loving, best pal of Icky Ricky Santorum, sibling *admits* that the nation is fucked. F.U.C.K.E.D. And there is no “American dream” no more. My sib is “forced” to continue paying 2 of her kids’ (both in their 30s) rent & sometimes auto ins because they simply cannot cobble together enough part-time jobs to pay all of their expenses. Sib & spouse expect to keep working into early 70s at least (like good little dittoheads, they do as their told by el Lushbo). Kids are highly educated and not slackers; just no jobs, esp not full time jobs.
My sib admits that nearly ALL of their pals (and believe me, they are all very rightwing “Christiany” Fox & Friends types) are in the same boat with Gen X kids either living at home and/or boomer parents still paying rent and other expenses.
My sib is somewhat at a LOSS to figure it all out, yet my sib still bewails that taxes and regulations are a huge, giant sucking “problem.”
I dunno… not real sure that these fairy tale memes about living la vida loca IF ONLY you just “work hard enough” will do the trick this time around, even with the Tea Party.
My family has LONG been a real bellweather of the coming trends in this once-great land of ours. Just saying…
As was noted on Rumproast, the idea of Rinsus Repeatus (h/t Betty Cracker) extolling a “union electrician” while he chairs the party that has successfully led the way in decimating unions, is so funny I forgot to laugh. As is Rinsus’s calling Harry Reid “a dirty liar” as he shills for the biggest candidate liar of all time.
And yet George Snuffleupagus (h/t Charlie Pierce) doesn’t call him on it. What an unfortunate oversight.
My Repub pal, who is volunteering for the Rmoney campaign, is an example of the mesmerized Mitt-puppet crowd. He’s a tattooed, ex-convict, who happens to work a job that pays about 100K/yr. He just knows that he’ll be a self-made millionaire, someday. That he’s been in this gig for many years, and hasn’t got ‘there’ yet has no effect on his enthusiasm for all things Mitt. I realized that his prison experience has given him decidely racist views, his father (who was also a convicted white-collar crook) served to show him that hard work is good, but makes a great cover for thievery- until you get caught. He’s been caught selling illicit pharmacueticals and fraud. I think he’s well on his way to success, if Rmoney wins and brings that ‘business friendly’ regime to power in America. I was going to leave the country when Dubya got in, but, like a schmuck, I didn’t. If Mitt wins, I’m not staying- I am not going to have to kick myself in the ass for not escaping when the chance presents itself.
Beautifully written, TBogg. Keep it coming – it’s the only way we’re going to survive this frickin’ campaign.
Reince Priebus:
Re: Penis Ice Rub
Re: Bi Penis Cure
Cure Bier Penis
Penis Cuber Ire
Penis Brier Cue
Ecru Penis Brie
Because Republicans are dicks…
“Behind every great fortune there is a great crime,” while perhaps not actually written by Honoré de Balzac, does seem an apt summary of something he did write. (source)
Hey, perhaps father of TBogg would have accepted the unconsumed portion of a beverage of his customer, in lieu of being paid… Naw, maybe not.
[The folks who stiffed TBogg's Dad were probably not the great criminals themselves, but may have been their henchman, something like the lawyers and accountants on Wall Street or K Street.]
@BOHICA Quoting Barbara Ehrenreich AND Firesign Theatre in the same post:
Priceless.
@TheSpoiler: Take out the vowels and you have RNC PR BS (^@Sharoney)
::
“Kochsucker” – beautiful! Willard and Rove are Kochsuckers.
Yeah, I love the way they repeat versions of this story: See that rich guy? He’s a wonderful man, and you should want to be like him! And they treat that as a normal human interaction. Um, well. I’m the same age as Marco Rubio. In my family, which wasn’t exactly privileged but didn’t have working-class authenticity either, we were quite happy saying, instead, See that rich guy? He’s an idiot and a crook.
And these are the same people who stoke resentment against unions, saying union members have it too easy because they bargained for somewhat better benefits (usually in exchange for lower pay raises, or even pay freezes or cuts).
One of your very best posts ever, Mr Bogg. And that’s the best of a very good lot.
Indeed. My mom tells me stories about North Dakota farmers in the ’30s who spoke Norwegian only. Of course they also had the advantage of being the right hue.
American Dream ™. Buy it or else.
Yes, there are a few neighborhoods in San Diego where these folks congregate. La Jolla, The Ranch (Rancho Santa Fe), Scripps Ranch, and near my old stomping grounds, Del Cerro.
Making deliveries in Del Cerro for a liquor store was a load of laughs. Daytime deliveries varied from your Dad’s scenario to “come around the side and accept a few crumpled dollars for the generic vodka, and please god don’t put it on the account or he’ll kill me”.
Night time deliveries were a crap shoot. Either you got a great tip (usually the Johnny Walker folks), or were told to drop off the Jack (never did, that was the owners’ kids calling), or you had to show them how to tap the keg.
Good Times
I concur, definitely bullshit. My dad struggled through the Depression, improved his lot over that of his parents, and became as conservative as any Republican of the 50′s and 60′s. He would drive us around town, pointing out the big houses with the fancy cars. But unlike the fantasy dads Preibus and Rubio, what he said was, “See that house? They don’t own that. The bank owns it. They’re one paycheck away from being out on the street. That Cadillac, they don’t own that, the bank does. Miss a payment and they’ll be walking.” Along came the recession in the early 70′s and bingo, those houses were on the market. The deli went out of business because those folks didn’t pay off the big tabs they’d run up.
Real conservatives don’t love people with big houses and fancy cars. They love savers, who shun credit and pay cash, who own the stuff they use. And they know how hard it is to make enough to afford the trappings of today’s wealthy without cheating.
Tea Party Republicans aren’t conservatives. They’re uninformed, scared, and angry. And easily led around by their prejudices.
How odd. When we pointed out a fancy car or house to our parents, they usually took the opportunity to reinforce the lesson that material wealth wasn’t a worthy goal. Honesty, craftsmanship, kindness, and understanding — these were the important goals.
Of course this was pre-Reagan so maybe the American Dream was different back then.
Not that Reince’s dad had a union job. Not so many of those left any more.
Back in my waitressing days I learned two things:
1) the absolute best tippers (and generally most pleasant to wait on) are working class, union guys.
2) the hardest working person in the place is the dishwasher–who also makes the least amount $$$ and takes the most crap.
I also worked much, much harder when I was an entry level manager than when I was a director. At one hotel our GM, who definitely viewed himself as above the rest of us (even though he was around the same age, he addressed everyone by their first names, while we called him “Mr. Jones”), spent most of the work week playing golf and blaming everyone for the hotel’s red ink bleeding.
My family’s immigrant story was a bit different from Rubio’s.
My grandfather (an itinerant butcher in the old country) came to Highland Park to work for $5/day. Henry Ford put him in the foundry and he lasted until he was about 60 years old, dieing from the effects of working around molten metal and dirt for 35 years. He never could afford to own a house.
During the early part of the 20th century we got intelligence test to prove that immigrants were so dumb that they were only qualified for jobs like foundry work. Then we got prohibition because we couldn’t have those whose names ended in a vowel being drunk when they came to work. And then we got the Great Depression that screwed everybody.
Granted, there are decent rich folks, but history shows that the monied class see the working class as something to be used, and used up. No different than iron ore, a forest, or the nearest river. (Who paid to clean up Lake Erie? Not Ford or Great Lakes Steel.)
Exploitation of the middle class is now a virtue, so prized that you can even make a run for president based on it.
Brilliant posts the last couple days, Tbogg.
The first time I read the Priebus quote I was struck by its Once in a Lifetime vibe (You may ask yourself, what is that beautiful house?). Though I’m pretty sure David Byrne’s intent was not quite the same as the anagram’s.
And the post’s title reminds me that Neil Young and Crazy Horse are out on tour this fall. Smell the Horse!
Oh also, too, funny how none of them ever consider the Kenyan Muslin Interloper to embody the American Dream of overcoming challenges through hard work and one’s own initiative….
Cause, you know, the Blah….
The best tippers are those who once worked for tips, like my four sisters and myself. Back when I was a busboy in the summers (1960s), I made $1 an hour plus a share of the waitresses’ tips. They made $0.33 an hour plus tips. People who stiff them for any reason they can think of are assholes.
Stiffing the waitstaff, dodging a bill, scamming the people you work with – every sharp practice we warned about as children – these are now the marks of the predator class, great and small. They may not have been prosecuted but they’re crooked and they behave like crooks. There’s nothing admirable about them and if the Unpronounceable Spokesman was shown them as role models his people were as thick and foolish as he is.
Shows how old-fashioned I am; silly me, I thought the American dream was to live in a country where everybody could participate in governing themselves and could speak their minds without fear of jail and could go (or not go) to whatever church they wanted. My parents certainly told me over and over again that integrity and character count for much more than material possessions do.
And double on what our Noble Host Mr. Bogg said about the rich. I’ll never forget a dinner party where the overdressed hostess and her harpy friends boasted of putting a bed in a walk-in closet and calling it “the maid’s room,” while whining about the maids’ ingratitude and unwillingness to accept wages that (in the immortal words of Robert Heinlein, of all people) “a plumber’s helper would scorn.”
‘we were warned about’
“To which I said, ‘it’s suckers like them that help keep me rich!’”
Onitgoes — send her this video link. Tell her it bashes Democrats, that’ll sucker her into watching it.
Brine Uric Seep: “And I still believe them, since like most Republicans I never progressed beyond the mental age of 8, and still believe in jingoistic fairy tales and simpleton authoritarian feel-good stories (or find them useful to propagandize the rubes)”
West London
Crouch’d on the pavement close by Belgrave Square
A tramp I saw, ill, moody, and tongue-tied;
A babe was in her arms, and at her side
A girl; their clothes were rags, their feet were bare.
Some labouring men, whose work lay somewhere there,
Pass’d opposite; she touch’d her girl, who hied
Across, and begg’d and came back satisfied.
The rich she had let pass with frozen stare.
Thought I: Above her state this spirit towers;
She will not ask of aliens, but of friends,
Of sharers in a common human fate.
She turns from that cold succour, which attneds
The unknown little from the unknowing great,
And points us to a better time than ours.
Matthew Arnold
I have a client who is opening a doughnut shop. She first said “Obama said “you didn’t build that..blahblahblah”" I mentioned how that was taken out of context. Later, she was talking about her wealthy landlord and I said how rich guys like Romney want tax cuts and then take so many breaks they pay nothing and us workers are stuck with the bill. She wholeheartedly concurred but I don’t think she really picked up on it. It’s out there, folks, we just have to find a way t catapult our message….(heheheh)
Typical that Republicans measure “The American Dream” by the yardstick of accumulated stuff. Talk about missing the point of FREEEEDOMMMM11!1
And Mr. Bogg? This. I vote this post as being your best yet.
The one thing that can be said in the Pissants of the Universe’s favor: they bring out the Best in the Bogg!
They put the muck in muckrake.
Also, besides: I’m thoroughly digging everyone’s family and personal stories.
Wow, I just went to La Jolla a few weeks ago. It was like sym city, bumper car alert. My son lives there on prospect, and close to coast. I have never seen so many people in my life, all different colors, all different languages. I am not sure if it is because of UCSD, (and my son is a renter). I was planning on staying a couple of weeks, but it was incredibly hot and humid (and I live in Folsom), no AC, barking birds on the roof, that sounded like they would kill each other. Seriously, I will come back when things have calmed down. My son is also a soccer player (formerly), likes to work out, etc. We flew him home for Thanksgiving, I spent several hours making turkey, and all the good things, HE WENT TO TRADER Joes and asked if I would be “mad” if he made a skinless, chicken breast. God, almighty, what is wrong with that. He grew up in California, but that really corked me up. Love your writing style.
Great lead post and stories. Good stuff y’all!
My dad was a small business owner for most of his working life. Two things, first,my parents never mentioned this when you grow up you can live in a house like that. Just never came up. The only thing I was told about growing up and being like x person was if you study hard you can be that smart. Second, I used to help out at my dad’s business and I can tell you of the clients who screwed us, 75 percent were wealthy and could afford to pay the bill but would find some BS stuff to bitch about. OTOH, “poorer” people were way easier to deal with. You did the job and got paid for it.
This reminds me of the bit in…hmmm, was it Anna Karenina? Or an English 19th century novel….anyway, a comment to the effect that it was uncool (18th cent. equivalent) of the aristocratic gamblers to actually pay the bills sent by their tailors, but it was absolutely dishonorable in the extreme to fail to pay a gambling debt (to another aristocrat,of course).
Anthony Trollope’s “The Way We Live Now” is one that touches that. Hard.
My “the rich are different from you and me” story: college summers driving ice-cream truck… yeah, poor neighborhood moms bought the nicest ice-creams, joked around, gave me close to exact change while rich bitch mothers would hand me a twenty to pay for junior’s 25-cent popsicle.
Yes, we all know the American Dream is to own your own house. They never quite mention that the American nightmare is some legacy-hire trust-fund baby with enough money for four houses.
When I was growing up in the late 70’s, my parents would look at the beautiful house on the corner and say, “see the plumber that’s fixing that house? He’s union and has a decent wage, healthcare and a pension. No one would ever dare refer to him as a parasite. And the people that own this fine house pay their fair share of taxes (a top marginal rate of 70%) without funneling them through shell corporations in Bermuda, the Canary Islands, and Swiss Bank accounts (so they can have five other estates with dancing horses that taxpayers subsidize) so that we can have excellent public schools and sufficient infrastructure and social security.” I knew we should respect people like that.
Then they’d point out a smaller, but still nice, comfortable house and say, “see those people? The Dad works for the telephone company and they can afford a car and put their children through college on his job alone. There’s no way anyone would outsource their jobs to squeeze a few extra dollars of profit for ‘job creator’ investment class parasites that somehow only destroy American businesses, or to pay his CEO 400 times his yearly salary.”
Then they said, “God help us if Reagan is elected and instead of continuing the longest economic expansion and wage growth for the middle class in history, we instead have to suffer through 30 years of economic catastrophe because of corrupt conservative tax policies and union busting that favor enriching the 0.1% at the expense of the 99.9%.” And I knew no one could, or even should, respect people like that. Except for, of course, people like that.
Then Dad joked, “but never fear, because after those Republican parasites are in charge people will hate them so much they’d probably even elect a Kenyan-born Marxist.”
And Mummykins and Da were right! That’s how much America hates Conservatives and their policies.
~ Harry R. Sohl
Stiffing the merchant or workman is a classic aristocratic value. It shows up all the time in 19th century novels. The aristocratic code differed a great deal from the mercantile code. A merchant would move heaven and earth to pay off a debt for goods or services rendered. An aristocrat would move heaven and earth to pay off a debt of honor, a gambling debt, but would rusticate, head out to the country house, to avoid paying wine, clothing and other such bills. On the other hand, an aristocrat wouldn’t abandon a buddy in a fight, so unlike the American rich, the code had a positive side.