Remember when NPR got all huffy-puffy when Lisa Simeone, the host of World of Opera got in trouble and stuff because she supported Occupy Wall Street by hate-playing La bohème (which is an Italian communist opera based upon the popular American musical Rent) over and over until banksters started to feel twinges of guilt that they quickly got over by strangling a hooker in the back of a limo? Yeah, there was some kind of ethical/conflict of interest thing problem, by which we mean the financial institutions who underwrite NPR were mildly chafed by Simeone’s obstreperousness.
Well say hello to Adam Davidson of NPR’s Planet Money and the New York Times who knows the difference between who signs the front of the check and who signs on the back:
Adam Davidson is the co-creator and host of the popular economic news radio program Planet Money. On air, Davidson plays the role of an earnest, brainy reporter who’s doing his best to make sense of the complicated, jargon-filled world of finance to report business news in a way that NPR listeners can understand. However, behind the dweeby, faux-naive facade Adam Davidson presents to his listeners, is a shrewd propagandist with a long, consistent history of shilling for powerful and destructive interests—and failing to disclose his financial ties to the companies and industries he reports on.
[...]
While Adam Davidson has recently come under increasing scrutiny for using his NPR platform to promote the narrow interests of the super-wealthy in this country, little attention has thus far been given to Davidson’s corruption—his numerous financial conflicts of interest that seriously undermine his claims to being a journalist, and instead reveal Davidson as a glorified product spokesman for his Wall Street sponsors.
You see, Adam Davidson’s sonorous business gabfest is sponsored exclusively by Ally Bank (the artist formerly known as GMAC) and they are kind of bad people:
To understand why Davidson’s arrangement with Ally Bank is so odious, a little background is needed. Ally Bank is a subsidiary of Ally Financial, a giant financial services company formerly known as GMAC. There’s a good reason why GMAC would have wanted to change its name to “Ally Financial” after the financial collapse: The bank is one of the biggest mortgage servicers in the country, and has been one of the very worst offenders in foreclosure fraud and in the very same subprime fraud that Davidson whitewashed as a “blameless” phenomenon. GMAC deserves far more blame—and jail time—than any of the subprime borrowers it fleeced and ruined. Since GMAC collapsed in late 2008, it has received more than $17 billion taxpayer bailout funds in a series of bailouts. As of August 1, 2012, 74% of Ally Financial was still owned by the U.S. Government. [ 1 ]
At the time Ally signed its sponsorship agreement with Planet Money, the bank was being investigated across the country for foreclosure fraud, robo-signing fraud, and student loan fraud. Even as bad bailed-out banks go, GMAC/Ally is considered one of the worst, most tainted of them all.
Yeah, but that doesn’t mean that Davidson is some kind of bank-fellating manwhore, does it?
One example: In 2009, just as Planet Money inked its exclusive sponsorship deal with Ally Bank, Davidson began broadcasting a number of segments critical of the proposed Financial Consumer Protection Agency Act of 2009, questioning the need to regulate consumer financial products like mortgages and credit cards in order to protect people against bank fraud. “Will it work at all?” Davidson asked in one of his fake “gee-whiz” questions. “Is this just one more layer of regulation in a regulatory system that fundamentally broke down?”
In May 2009, in the heat of the banking industry’s massive pushback, Davidson essentially mugged Elizabeth Warren, the chief architect of the financial consumer protection bill, in an interview that took a sharp and bizarre hostile turn early on. Davidson surprised Warren and his own listeners with uncharacteristic personal smears, trying to portray her as a clueless, power-hungry ideologue. Davidson’s attack on Warren was so out-of-line and uncharacteristically hostile that it sparked a torrent of criticism from NPR listeners who couldn’t understand why Davidson or NPR would do such a thing.
Okay, maybe he is. So what’s up with that, Adam Davidson?
The Columbia Journalism Review described the Planet Money interview as a “disaster” and “really cringeworthy stuff from Davidson,” who was so rude and unprofessional that NPR’s Ombudsman was forced to issue a public apology for his behavior. Davidson’s excuse: he had been traveling for a NPR fundraiser and was “very, very tired.”
That’s like the Twinkie Defense but without all the preceding shooty stuff.
But lest you think that NPR’s highly ethical Adam Davidson is a monogamous one-bank at a time kind of guy, well, he’s not above pulling a bank train if the price is right:
On top of Ally Bank’s exclusive sponsorship of Planet Money, Davidson earns lucrative speaking fees from banks and financial companies, including J.P. Morgan, Well Fargo, Bank of America and Goldman Sachs—the same companies he covers as a journalist. Davidson is frequently the only journalist/reporter booked to speak at these events; other speakers usually work in finance.
Davidson has yet to disclose his corporate clients and how much they pay him, but here is a partial list of Davidson’s speaking gigs from the last two years compiled from various publicly available sources:
- In April 2011, Davidson was the headlining speaker at the 9th Annual “Women’s World Banking” Microfinance and the Capital Markets Conference. The conference was hosted by J.P. Morgan, but the organization itself is funded by the world’s biggest banks and corporations, including BP, Morgan Stanley, Pfizer, Barclays Capital, VISA, ExxonMobil—just to name a few.
- In 2011, Davidson spoke at another microfinance conference, this once was also funded by Morgan Stanley, Citi, Bank of America, Deutsche Bank and CapitalOne.
- In 2012, Davidson spoke at the 27th Annual Conference for the Treasury & Finance Professional. Sponsors of the event included Bank of America, BlackRock, BNY Mellon, Bloomberg, Citibank, Findelity Investments, Goldman Sachs, J.P. Morgan, Morgan Stanley, Well Fargo and about a dozen of the most powerful financial the largest financial companies in the world.
Obviously NPR needs to take a stand on this.
Maybe on All Things Considered they’ll propose a blogger ethics panel.
We haven’t had one of those in a while and we could use a good cleansing…





26 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
This really pisses me off; I like Planet Money.
I stopped listening at one point because I had other things on my plate and never got around to getting caught up, but I still have some of their podcast episodes saved on my computer. I didn’t hear the Elizabeth Warren interview but I heard about it; I thought Davidson’s excuse was pretty weak but it never occurred to me that there may have been ulterior motives. Blah.
You are on fire this week, sir. Keep it up, if you can!
The Bank Dick is no mere corporate shill. He seems to be a member in good standing in our Secret Government. Perhaps he is a secret leader in the five million member American KGB Espionage Complex.
He has helped win the war in Irak in his own way.
I listen to more NPR than I probably should. Last pledge drive I nearly weakened and gave. I’m glad I didn’t.
Sounds like Davidson would be perfect as Rmoney’s Treasury Sec.
And I just love, love this line: La bohème (which is an Italian communist opera based upon the popular American musical Rent)
On top of Ally Bank’s exclusive sponsorship of Planet Money, Davidson earns lucrative speaking fees from banks and financial companies, including J.P. Morgan, Well Fargo, Bank of America and Goldman Sachs—the same companies he covers as a journalist.
This cannot be true, I thought David Broder was dead.
TBogg for the win:
“hate-playing La bohème (which is an Italian communist opera based upon the popular American musical Rent)”
Do you have, like, a big trophy case where you keep all the internets you have won?
I remember that Warren interview, but didn’t know there was such a kerfuffle over it. Good, it was an embarrassment.
Planet Money has some interesting stories and solid reporting, but the personalities of the hosts/reporters are hard to take, led by Davidson who is the embodiment of the worst aspects of Ira Glass turned up to eleven but minus the charm.
I simply won’t know what to think about this until I have a chance to consult with David Brooks.
That Lisa Simeone story still makes me sad, and angry. As best as I can tell, she still has her opera show, though apparently NPR doesn’t pick it up as an optional offering anymore (I assume local stations can continue to do so).
Hope Ms. Simeone is doing well, and is continuing to be the best kind of citizen, despite all.
I have to admit, the news and commentary on the local PBS affiliate (San Diego) has been somewhat skewed since Joan Kroc kicked this mortal coil leaving them a sh*tload of money–for news and information programming.
I may be a little late picking up on this, but I think it’s a serious contender for best new word of the year:
“BANKSTAS”
Courtesy Graydon Carter (or whoever writes his headlines) in Vanity Fair
Well, Broder’s stinky Wallabys, sitting in the corner since The Dean got planted six feet under, weren’t going to walk into the bank safety deposit box themselves. Sounds like Davidson is well on his way to filling them as Broder’s heir to the well-compensated “journalist-speaker” at conventions of plutocrats he adoringly covers in his commentary.
Whore.
Maybe we should have joined forces with the knuckle draggers and helped bury this huge pile of excrement that has been rebranded and relaunched as NPR.
“Obviously NPR needs to take a stand on this.”
Obviously
“Maybe on All Things Considered they’ll propose a blogger ethics panel”
aaaaaaand, maybe not.
Wait, you mean people take Nonsensical Plutocratic Radio “News” seriously?
I have satellite radio and listen to a ton of NPR but TOTN, Marketplace and Planet Money drive me around the bend. I don’t get ME or ATC, thank god, but the other stuff is the stuff I love NPR – The Moth, Saltcast, From Scratch, TAL, Harry Shearer, Diane Rehm, WWDTM etc.
NPR better get rid of Davidson. Not that it matters, FBN(are they still around?),Bloomberg or CNBC will pick him up with a generous contract.
I’m an economics geek, and few things push my blood pressure higher than Planet Money. The scope of their reporting is on par with a third grader’s book report, yet they combine that with the most phenomenally condescending tone. It’s like a soft-sole hipster version of the shit you’d hear from a freshman who just read Atlas Shrugged.
If you want some real comedy, go dig up the interview they did with the spokesman for Goldman Sachs during the immediate aftermath of the 2008 meltdown. SOB didn’t have to bathe for a week after the tongue washing he got from Planet Money. (Then, for a palete cleanser, listen to the interview where Barny Frank called them morons.) Or look up this gawdfuckingawful piece Davidson wrote for the NYT last November.
There are a lot of reasons journalism is screwed seven ways from Sunday, but I firmly believe one big reason is that reporting shifted from a trade to a profession. NPR is the textbook case.
Cleansing?
It’s distinctly possible that Davidson could use a serious high colonic.
Recently, you have been writing like a man possessed, or one that has made a Faustian bargain- a deal with the Devil. Your nuanced verse is having the same effect of a Robert Johnson or Led Zeppelin on us dirty unwashed masses.
I feel the magic and it is totally cracking me up
Long May You Run!
(I’ve only heard about one and half episodes, but…) their condescending, cutesy, faux-naive “conversational” delivery also means it takes them fifteen minutes to explain something that a knowledgeable person speaking normal adult English could explain in five minutes.
NPR is far,far more than one program. You condemn the entire network for the actions of one individual. Please rethink your position. Despite its warts NPR is still the best place, and, increasingly, the only place, for unbiased news reporting and interviews.
But…but they also have Cokie Roberts. Too. My iron-clad excuse for not contributing.
Hee, she is an acquired taste I guess. I am a member and have been for decades. Far too many excellent reporters to list, plus Teri Gross, plus Tom and Ray the tappet brothers.
I love the middle of the road reportage that allows one to hear all sidesa of issues and make up ones mind sans bias. Precisely what so many do not like.
meepmeep09,
Thank you. Yes, I’m still here. Yes, I’m still hosting World of Opera, which is still produced by WDAV as it was before; yes, I’m still hosting the Chicago Symphony Orchestra series, as I was before (and which no crack reporter seemed to figure out last year); yes, I’m still living in Baltimore and still writing for Style magazine, which so far has been unperturbed by my political activities; and yes, I’m still trying to be a good citizen and am still politically active.
And yes, the stench of hypocrisy is so strong right now that I barely have a sense of smell left.
Since it was called to my attention by an alert acquaintance, I have sent the Adam Davidson story to everyone on my mailing list, which includes various journalists and the few people at NPR who are still speaking to me (yes, cliched but true: when adversity calls, you quickly find out who your friends are and who they aren’t).
So far, none of the journalists who lectured me on “ethics” last year have responded. And so far, this story has gotten only the tiniest bit of coverage — here, at the New York Observer, at Alternet, at Democratic Underground, and at Huffington Post. That’s all I can find.
We all know why. It’s okay if you toe the corporate line, not okay if you oppose it.
Even though I was not an NPR employee, did not get paid by NPR, and did not even cover politics, NPR made a huge stink about my involvement in the Occupy movement. Yet here is Adam Davidson, an actual NPR employee, apparently taking payola from the corporations he reports on, and there’s nary a peep.
Oh, well. Just another example of, “All Animals Are Equal, But Some Animals Are More Equal Than Others.”
I don’t listen to NPR anymore, period. They were co-opted long ago by corporate and military interests. Funny, my ‘liberal’ friends exude pride whenever they announce I heard on NPR…yada, yada, yada, as if NPR was the final arbiter of journalistic truth. Yeah, much of it’s programming is benign, but it avoids causing discomfiture like the plague.