
Scenes from the Worst Oscar viewing party in the world:
Though there are a few (for Hollywood, strikingly) candid acknowledgments of historical fact, Argo obscures far more than which country bears greater acclaim for the successful extraction of the embassy staffers. Yes, it makes a nod to historical fact concerning Mossadegh, and the discerning might wonder exactly what the staffers were so eager to burn/destroy – we can surmise from Wikileaks releases on the Clinton State Department, that at the very least, the documents addressed considerable influene(sic)/pressure brought on the Iranian government to accede to international business concerns at the expense of its citizens.
But, it is, interestingly, a movie where Iranians barely exist, until our heroic gang successfully dupes the beauracratic (sic) airport security rubes. Otherwise, we are mostly given montages of the direct counterparts of the CIA, who were in all likeliehood (sic), trained by the CIA, or perhaps tortured by SAVAK officers trained by the CIA, in which case even such single minded devotion warrants that explanation. And they are shown as inhuman caricatures, devoid of humor or life as they try to track down the missing staffers. This in direct contrast to the fairly warm view of Bryan Cranston’s character and the assemblage of supporting Langley players.
“Life of Pi” is, at end, an upper class fantasy that whitewashes the West’s interference in the colonies. Go to the wealthy area of your town, throw a rock in any direction and you will inevitably hit a well-off woman who gushes about how good and meaningful it is and all other sorts of pablum. That alone should key you in immediately to the fact that there is something deeply wrong with it.
When it is pointed out that Life of Pi is apolitical:
I admit I don’t know how to see story as apolitical or disconnected from the context in which it emerges. What I observe is that while hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers commit suicide, or one might more rightly say are murdered by Monsanto and its GMO cronies (speaking of socializing lobbyist expenses in the form of the State Department), and tens of millions strike against the grinding poverty that is neoliberalism’s aim (the wealthy are rich as a direct consequence of making others poor), the West once again fetishizes the spirituality of its colonies. And, of course, the film quite literally fetishizes the young, handsome and conveniently bare-chested native. It’s nearly as sickening as the hackneyed noble British pensioners retire in the former colonies meme (with full cast of regular British character actors), and it obscures the far darker truth that Orwell, Conrad and Greene so eloquently laid bare.
So that’s what I saw.
I remember how I couldn’t enjoy Harold and Kumar Go To White Castle because there are people who are starving in North Korea so, really, it was the longest 88 minutes of my life….




38 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About TBogg
RSS/XML Feed
…Ruh-roh…
Wow, that’s like a lefty version of one of Roy Edroso’s Kulturkampf regulars. Sometimes a movie is just a movie, few chrissakes.
Every (hic) goddamned (hic) mispelling and grammatical fuck up (hic), I started reading the [sic] brackets to indicate OP’s incompetence as inebriation. This is more than charitable, as drunks all around the world will start tomorrow a little bit more sober than their current state.
Wingnuts and dumbfucks will simply wake up.
and then the coda:
TL;DR Obama hates brown people, and Ang Lee is an elitist, just like all those nameless elitist women, living in elitist enclaves.
Adam Serwer was gloating about Kathryn Bigelow not winning anything because, you know, she didn’t make the anti-torture movie that Adam Serwer would have made.
I followed the Oscars via Twitter…
I’m thinking I was rather well informed on this particular shindig.
P.S. Relevant to Mr. Bogg’s comment at #4:
I know exactly how you felt; I’ve been feeling guilty lately about eating anything at all. Those sybarites who gorge on things like barbecued shrimp over linguine have a lot to answer for, I’ll tell you.
PS – you’re sounding cranky at the moment. Please continue.
I was too busy preparing to lose my job courtesy of the sequester to participate in the festivities. Arthur watched – noted a singular lack of Dogs among the competitors and suggested that the oversight was part of a deeply political, ingrained contempt for the Other in modern society.
Don’t turn around
(uh oh)
Der Kommisar’s in town
(oh uh oh)
no, no, no, he’s right. In “Pi” the tiger, which is on Exxon’s logo, represents US oil interests, is stuck in a small lifeboat (i.e. the world) and will devour the peoples of the developing nations (Pi) unless the Tiger is feed and placated. It’s a clear metaphor for why the poor of the world owe their lives to the forbearance of the military/petroleum complex.
No, no, no. In “Life of Pi” the Tiger represents Exxon and the major petroleum interests. Pi represents the peoples of the developing world. The tiger has a legitimate need to be fed, and Pi is there solely for the purpose of feeding the tiger and keeping him alive. “Life” is a clear metaphor for why the interests of the military/oil complex come before the needs of the world’s poor!
Yes sir, we’ll show Victor Hugo what it really means to be “the miserable ones.” His characters had good reason to be that way. We spare no effort to make ourselves that way.
My favorite quote:
This reminds me of the great Lady and the Tramp dissection in my third grade class. Essentially, the consensus boiled it down to being a near criminal portrayal of the bourgeois (Lady) consuming more than her fair share of the wealth of the people (spaghetti) than the Tramp (proletariat).
It was quite the kerfuffle; crayons were thrown, pudding cups overturned, pants peed…
Somewhere, somehow, there’s a Blazing Saddles reference to be made here, but damn if I’ll be the one to make it, these fuckers are serious, deep thinkers.
I’m tired.
C’mon now, I agree that the criticism is overwought and a tad precious but, since it’s here at FDL, if you have an issue go the source. Dragging it over here to take shots at it, while funny and on point as usual, is kinda weak…ducking…..
A couple of things.
Out of respect for Kevin I don’t post comments on his posts. His audience is his audience and mine is mine, with precious little crossover I would guess. Most of his readers think I’m History’s Greatest Monster and, to be honest, I don’t give a fuck what they think, but it is still his territory.
Having said that… to me source material is source material whether it is on RedState, Breitbart or even FDL. Stupidity and pretentiousness observe no boundaries.
All “meaningful” art is bourgeois decadence designed to beguile the masses into thinking they are participating in political of cultural change by merely experiencing the creations of self congratulating narcissists.
Also drones.
Lefty anti-intellectualism is quite the niche market.
Does this mean “Freddie deBoer Got Fingered” isn’t going to be a comedy?
And Lincoln like TOTALLY took his time freeing the slaves, and only kind of freed them with the Emancipation Proclamation not really no take backsies.
So Lincoln sucked too.
Ah, I see. Wasn’t aware of the intra-FDL dynamics in play. Your overall angle makes sense too. Carry on!
Maybe he was just getting into the “It’s all about me” spirit of the evening?
Also, danielx @ 6, “P.S. – you’re sounding cranky at the moment. Please continue.” gets my internets winner vote.
It’s much more fun to laugh at the right wing outrage that Michelle Obama “crashed” the Oscars.
Best Oscar viewing party: http://www.lostwackys.com/celebrities/01-hollywood-Zombies.htm
To be fair, I believe they were discussing film over there. Not to be confused with the movies, which I personally enjoy tremendously.
On that note however, the Dan nailed it back in the 70′s:
“Show Bizness Kids making movies of themselves you know they don’t give a fuck about anybody else you know you go to…”
Mine too! I didn’t get out of the boat but I’d bet “the dissenter” also complained about the pampered aristocrat heroine of Brave winning out over the working-class hero of Wreck-It Ralph.
Are you saying you aren’t History’s Greatest Monster? I blame Obama.
I think that there’s reasonable constructive criticism that can be lobbed at Argo, since it is based on actual events. Ben Affleck took some “artistic license” with the story that perhaps went a bit too far. That said, I liked the movie and thought it was well done. When I watch a Hollywood movie – as opposed to a documentary – my truthiness standards are relaxed, shall we say.
As for Life of Pi, gimme a break. If I have to apply such rigorous standards to every work of fiction that I read or watch, I might as give up now. Someone needs to take a chill pill, a deep breath, and perhaps locate a sense of humor.
Perhaps smoking some of Kumar’s whacky weed is in order to gain a sense of balance??? Or something???
My comment when I saw that was: Rush Limpdick must be dancing the happiest of happy dances right now! Boyohboy did he *ever* get “good material” for today’s tirading rant for the sore losers!
Agree with TBogg….pretentious…obnoxious… obsessive…batshit crazy… when any of it is taken seriously by large numbers of people, someone has to point out the emperor’s nudity.
In the comment thread, “johnnyred” delivers a great many shots that the world’s worst oscar party host seems not be able to process, so deep is he into his own mental masturbation.
Go to the wealthy area of your town, throw a rock in any direction and you will inevitably hit a well-off woman
Violence! Aggression! Patriarchy! Also, my town doesn’t even have a ‘wealthy area’, you assumption-maker, you!
Didn’t Jimbo post something along this line the other day?
Obviously Jake is one of the privileged few who can afford rocks to say nothing of his carelessly just throwing them around like they were worth nothing. Why, in China, kids would kill to have a rock of their own.
I’ve shied away from watching Life of Pi because I so loved the book. It sounds like they’ve truncated the ending, which was quiet, powerful, and explanatory, piece. I guess I will see it on #D.
If you haven’t done so, go read the the book.
Hey, T, fix the linkies in the post above!
I’m thinking a sock with horse manure in it, attached to a laser-guided missile, which would (of course) be launched from a drone…you know, for accuracy.
But that’s just me…
really? funny how that works. they assigned it as required reading for my 11-year old. i read it and objected – as material fit for a 11-year old.
as for me. i found the book pretentious, casually violent and just plain silly pop-philosophy.
didn’t really see the worth.
just me, though.